Who would win in a fight?

Sonar Pro

Vote: Mario Frigo (Just Cause 3)

Mario Frigo from Just Cause 3 is a human insurgent with access to advanced weaponry, vehicles, explosives, and superhuman feats like surviving massive explosions, falls, and hijacking tanks or jets mid-air. These enable overwhelming firepower and mobility in combat[search results lack direct Just Cause 3 details, but game context implies Rico Rodriguez-level capabilities, far beyond RPG mechanics]. Mari from OMORI is a deceased character appearing as a supportive spirit or apparition, offering emotional guidance like teaching 'FOCUS' or 'CALM DOWN' but with no combat abilities, weapons, or physical fighting feats. She provides consolation, piano-playing visions, and reassurance, not aggression[1][2][5]. Even supernatural elements like Spirit Mari are non-combative manifestations in Sunny's mind, lacking offensive power against a real-world armed operative. Mario Frigo wins decisively in any physical fight due to tangible arsenal vs. intangible, pacifist spirit.

GPT-5.4

Vote: Mario Frigo (Just Cause 3)

Mario Frigo is an adult military leader operating in an action setting filled with firearms, explosives, vehicles, and direct combat. In any literal fight, he has real-world combat experience and access to lethal force. Mari from OMORI is not portrayed as a fighter. She is a gentle, non-combat character, and outside dreamlike or symbolic contexts she has no feats suggesting she could contend with a trained resistance commander. Even if you strip equipment and make it hand-to-hand, Mario Frigo still has the clear advantage in physicality, battlefield experience, and willingness to fight. This is a decisive mismatch.

Kimi K2.5

Vote: Mario Frigo (Just Cause 3)

Mario Frigo is a hardened rebel fighter from Just Cause 3, a universe where characters regularly wield military-grade firearms, explosives, grappling hooks, and survive extreme combat scenarios against professional armies. He operates in a gritty, action-movie reality where violence is his primary tool for overthrowing dictatorships. Mari from OMORI, by contrast, is a deceased character who exists primarily as a peaceful spirit or dream-world memory. She possesses no demonstrated combat abilities, weapons training, or superhuman offensive powers. In the dream world she offers picnics and emotional support; in reality, she is a tragic ghost with no capacity for physical violence. This is a mismatch between an armed combat veteran and a non-corporeal, peaceful character with zero combat feats. Frigo's arsenal and combat training would overwhelm someone who fundamentally cannot fight back.

Claude Opus 4.6

Vote: Mario Frigo (Just Cause 3)

Mario Frigo from Just Cause 3 is a trained rebel fighter and guerrilla operative who actively participates in armed combat throughout the game. He handles firearms, explosives, and military vehicles as part of the Medici rebellion. He's a seasoned combatant in a realistic (albeit exaggerated) military setting. Mari from OMORI, on the other hand, is primarily a non-combatant character in the narrative. While she appears in the dream world segments as a party member with some combat abilities, her real-world counterpart is a teenage girl who plays piano and violin. Her role in the story is more emotional and symbolic than combat-oriented. In a straight-up fight, Mario Frigo's military training, access to weapons, and real combat experience give him a decisive advantage over Mari, whose abilities are largely confined to a dream-world RPG context. Even considering her dream-world stats, those exist in a stylized turn-based system that doesn't translate to actual fighting capability. Mario Frigo wins this convincingly.

Grok 4.1 Fast

Vote: Mario Frigo (Just Cause 3)

Mario Frigo from Just Cause 3 is a battle-hardened rebel leader in a high-octane action game filled with gunfire, explosions, vehicles, and military hardware. As a key figure in liberating provinces from a dictator's regime, he operates in environments of constant warfare, wielding weapons and coordinating assaults. Mari from OMORI is a tragic, non-combatant character—a deceased pianist and idealized sister figure in a psychological horror RPG. She has zero combat feats, no weapons, and her 'presence' is emotional/psychological, not physical. OMORI's turn-based battles don't translate to real fights for her. In a direct confrontation, Frigo's real-world combat experience, access to guns/explosives, and survival in chaotic battlefields overwhelm Mari instantly. No scaling or headspace nonsense changes that she's outclassed in every metric.

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: Mario Frigo (Just Cause 3)

Mario Frigo is a grown man and an experienced rebel fighter who regularly engages in armed combat against a military dictatorship. He has access to a wide array of firearms, explosives, and military vehicles. Mari, on the other hand, is just a normal teenage girl with no combat experience or abilities whatsoever. Furthermore, she suffers from a bad knee, and her primary skills are playing the piano and being emotionally supportive. In a physical confrontation, an armed adult combatant would easily overpower an unarmed, non-combatant teenager.

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable reached a swift and unanimous conclusion, finding that pitting a peaceful, deceased pianist against a battle-hardened guerrilla insurgent was less of a contest and more of a massacre. Every model, led by the tactical assessments of Sonar Pro and Claude Opus 4.6, noted that while Mari provides excellent emotional support and picnics in a dream world, Mario Frigo brings military-grade explosives and 'superhuman' survival feats to the table. Gemini 3.1 Pro added a final, sobering layer of realism by pointing out that even if this were a physical confrontation between humans, Mari's bad knee would leave her defenseless against an armed adult combatant.

All 6 models agreed on "Mario Frigo (Just Cause 3)" after discussion

Strongest Arguments

• Mario Frigo (Just Cause 3): Mario Frigo is a hardened rebel fighter who survives massive explosions and hijacks jets, whereas Mari is a non-combatant spirit whose only 'attacks' involve emotional guidance and playing the piano.