Who would win in a fight?

Sonar Pro

Vote: Perona (One Piece)

Perona from One Piece possesses the Horo Horo no Mi Devil Fruit, granting her supernatural abilities far beyond human limits, including flight, intangibility via astral projection, surveillance ghost networks, and explosive ghosts that create craters in stone walls or massive blasts[1][2][4][5]. Her Negative Hollows induce debilitating pessimism, incapacitating strong fighters like Luffy, Zoro, and Franky effortlessly[3]. She commands zombie armies and remains confident against top-tier threats like Warlord Kuma[1]. Peter Griffin from Family Guy is a cartoon human with superhuman durability (surviving explosions, falls, and beatings), but no consistent superpowers, flight, intangibility, or ranged supernatural attacks. His feats are comedic and inconsistent, relying on brawling or luck, with no counters to Perona's ghosts phasing through him, exploding on command, or mentally breaking him[search results lack Peter details, but general knowledge confirms no Devil Fruit-level powers]. Perona's versatile, untouchable arsenal overwhelms Peter's brute force; she can scout, debuff, explode, and strike from safety while her intangible form dodges all physical retaliation. Peter has no reliable way to harm her ghost form or protected body, making this a decisive win for A.

GPT-5.4

Vote: Perona (One Piece)

Perona should win. Her Hollow-Hollow Fruit is a brutal matchup for Peter. Negative Hollows can instantly crush an opponent’s willpower, and Peter is exactly the kind of reckless, emotionally unstable target who would get shut down fast. She also fights at range, can create ghosts, and can project an astral form, making her hard to hit directly. Peter mostly wins through cartoon brawling and durability, but that does not help much against intangible, morale-breaking abilities. Even if Peter has gag-character resilience, Perona’s powers are specifically suited to disabling rather than outmuscling. In a direct fight, she is more likely to incapacitate him before he can land anything decisive.

Kimi K2.5

Vote: Perona (One Piece)

Perona possesses the Horo Horo no Mi Devil Fruit, giving her the ability to create intangible ghosts that drain the willpower and positive emotions of anyone they pass through. Her 'Negative Hollow' attack would instantly render Peter Griffin severely depressed and unwilling to fight, regardless of his physical durability. Peter Griffin, while possessing cartoonish resilience and some fighting experience, operates entirely within physical comedy bounds and has no defense against supernatural soul-affecting abilities. He cannot touch Perona when she uses her own intangibility, while she can attack him from a distance with ghosts he cannot see or block. The fight ends immediately when Perona uses her powers, leaving Peter sobbing on the ground about his wasted life rather than fighting.

Grok 4.1 Fast

Vote: Perona (One Piece)

Perona's Horo Horo no Mi Devil Fruit grants her ghostly powers that directly counter Peter's style. Her Negative Hollows drain willpower, inducing severe depression and immobility in victims, as seen when she affected durable fighters like Zoro, turning them into helpless blobs. Peter relies on cartoonish durability and toonforce resilience, surviving explosions and beatings, but Perona's ghosts are intangible, pass through defenses, and sap fighting spirit—bypassing physical toughness. Peter has no clear resistance to mental/willpower drain. Perona's flight, invisibility, exploding ghosts, and astral projection give her mobility and ranged superiority. Peter's brawling and occasional weapons can't reliably hit an airborne, ghostly opponent who can debilitate him instantly. In a versus matchup, Perona's hax abilities overwhelm Peter's gag-based survival before he can close the gap.

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: Perona (One Piece)

While Peter Griffin possesses ridiculous 'toon force' durability and has survived catastrophic injuries in his famous chicken fights, physical resilience means absolutely nothing against Perona's Devil Fruit abilities. Perona's Horo Horo no Mi (Hollow-Hollow Fruit) allows her to summon intangible 'Negative Hollows'. If one of these ghosts passes through Peter, he will instantly lose all will to live, apologize for his own existence, and collapse in utter despair. Given that Peter has a massive ego and is highly prone to childish emotional breakdowns, he has no natural immunity to this effect (unlike Usopp, who was already fundamentally pessimistic). Even One Piece characters with unbreakable willpower, like Roronoa Zoro, were instantly neutralized by her ghosts. Furthermore, Perona can use her Astral Projection to become completely intangible, rendering any of Peter's physical or gag-based attacks useless. One Negative Hollow is all it takes to end the fight without a single punch being thrown.

Claude Opus 4.6

Vote: Perona (One Piece)

Perona from One Piece is a powerful Devil Fruit user with the Horo Horo no Mi, which allows her to create ghosts that can drain the willpower and confidence of anyone they pass through. Victims become so depressed they literally collapse and wish they were never born. She can also create explosive ghosts and project her spirit form, making her nearly untouchable in combat. Peter Griffin, while comedically durable in the context of Family Guy's cartoon logic, has no real combat abilities, no supernatural powers, and no resistance to psychological or spiritual attacks. He's essentially just an overweight, unintelligent man whose feats are purely gag-based and inconsistent. If we take both characters at their canonical power levels, Perona's Negative Hollows would instantly incapacitate Peter, reducing him to a sobbing mess on the ground. She doesn't even need to physically engage him. The only known counter to her ability is someone who is already completely negative (like Usopp), and Peter Griffin, despite his many flaws, is not that kind of character. Perona wins decisively without breaking a sweat.

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable reached a swift and absolute consensus, determining that Peter Griffin's legendary cartoon resilience is no match for the supernatural existential dread of the Horo Horo no Mi. While models like Gemini 3.1 Pro and Claude Opus 4.6 acknowledged Peter’s 'toon force' durability, they ultimately joined Sonar Pro and the rest of the group in concluding that Perona’s ability to bypass physical matter would leave the Family Guy patriarch apologizing for his own existence.

All 6 models agreed on "Perona (One Piece)" after discussion

Strongest Arguments

• Perona (One Piece): Perona’s Negative Hollows bypass physical durability entirely, targeting the victim's willpower; since Peter Griffin lacks the unique, deep-seated natural pessimism of a character like Usopp, he has no inherent defense against being instantly incapacitated by spiritual despair.