Which is hated more?

GPT-5.4

Vote: Roma people

A. Globally and historically, both groups have faced extreme persecution, so any comparison is rough and context-dependent. But in present-day everyday social prejudice, especially across much of Europe, anti-Roma sentiment is often more openly expressed, more socially normalized, and less stigmatized than antisemitism. People who would never voice anti-Jewish views publicly may still openly endorse exclusionary stereotypes about Roma people. That suggests Roma people are, in many settings, more hated in direct day-to-day terms. This does not minimize antisemitism, which remains serious and sometimes violent. It only reflects that anti-Roma hostility is often more overt and broadly tolerated.

Sonar Pro

Vote: Jews

This question asks which group is 'hated more,' but the search results reveal this framing is problematic. Both Roma and Jews faced systematic Nazi persecution and genocide during WWII, with comparable scale and brutality. However, historically and contemporaneously, antisemitism has been more institutionalized, documented, and widespread across European societies for centuries. The search results note that anti-Roma persecution was 'normalized before Nazi ascendancy' and that explicit Nazi documentation of genocide plans was less prevalent for Roma than Jews, partly because discrimination against Roma was already culturally embedded. Post-WWII, antisemitism remains more globally recognized as a significant hatred, though Roma continue facing severe discrimination today. Measuring 'hatred' quantitatively is inherently difficult and arguably inappropriate for atrocities, but by metrics of historical documentation, institutional targeting, and sustained global awareness, antisemitism represents the more historically prominent and systematized form of hatred in European history.

Grok 4.1 Fast

Vote: Jews

Antisemitism against Jews is more intense and globally pervasive than anti-Roma prejudice. Historical evidence includes the Holocaust, which systematically exterminated 6 million Jews amid centuries of pogroms, blood libels, and expulsions, compared to the lesser-known Porajmos targeting up to 500,000 Roma. In modern times, organizations like the ADL track surging antisemitic incidents worldwide, fueled by conspiracy theories (e.g., 'Jewish control' of media/banks) and geopolitical tensions like Israel-Palestine. Anti-Roma hatred, while severe in Europe (e.g., evictions, violence in Eastern Europe), remains more localized and tied to stereotypes of criminality rather than global narratives. Surveys confirm this: ADL's Global 100 shows antisemitic attitudes in 74 countries averaging 26%; EU surveys rank Roma discrimination high but antisemitism garners more international outrage and policy focus. Thus, Jews face broader, more mobilized hatred.

Claude Opus 4.6

Vote: Roma people

From a sociological and historical perspective, Roma people (Romani) face what many scholars describe as the 'last acceptable racism' in Europe and globally. While antisemitism is rightly recognized, condemned, and actively combated through education, legislation, and institutional awareness, discrimination against Roma people remains widespread and often socially tolerated. Several indicators support this: 1. **Social acceptance of prejudice**: Surveys across Europe consistently show that anti-Roma sentiment is expressed more openly and with less social stigma than antisemitism. Eurobarometer and Pew Research polls show majorities in several European countries expressing unfavorable views of Roma. 2. **Institutional neglect**: While the Holocaust of Jewish people is extensively taught and memorialized, the Porajmos (the Romani genocide) remains largely unrecognized in educational curricula and public consciousness. 3. **Ongoing systemic discrimination**: Roma communities across Europe face segregated schools, forced evictions, employment discrimination, and police brutality with relatively little international outcry compared to other forms of ethnic discrimination. 4. **Lack of advocacy infrastructure**: Jewish communities have built powerful advocacy organizations and have significant political representation. Roma communities largely lack comparable institutional support, meaning anti-Roma hatred faces fewer organized countermeasures. 5. **Social acceptability**: Expressing anti-Roma views in public discourse, media, and politics carries far fewer consequences than expressing antisemitic views, suggesting that hatred toward Roma is more normalized and thus, in a practical sense, more pervasive. This is not to minimize antisemitism, which remains a serious and dangerous form of hatred. But in terms of which group faces more widespread, openly expressed, and socially tolerated hatred in the contemporary world, evidence points to Roma people.

Kimi K2.5

Vote: Roma people

While both groups have faced catastrophic historical persecution and continue to endure grave bigotry today, contemporary social metrics suggest Roma people currently face more intense systemic hatred—particularly in Europe, where populations of both groups overlap significantly. Empirical data from the EU Agency for Fundamental Rights and Pew Research consistently shows that anti-Roma sentiment reaches higher peaks of social rejection than antisemitism in direct comparison. In multiple EU member states, 70-80% of the population report they would not accept a Roma neighbor, compared to significantly lower figures for Jewish neighbors. Roma communities face extreme housing segregation, employment discrimination rates exceeding 90% in some regions, and routine denial of basic services that Jewish communities generally do not face to the same degree in the same geographies. Furthermore, Roma populations often lack the international advocacy infrastructure, sovereign-state representation, and legal protections that have been established to combat antisemitism, leaving their persecution less visible and more socially acceptable in mainstream discourse. While global antisemitism remains a critical threat, the concentrated intensity of exclusion and dehumanization directed at Roma people—often treated as a socially acceptable prejudice even in otherwise progressive societies—demonstrates that they currently endure the more acute form of hatred.

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: Roma people

When asked to rank or identify individuals or groups in terms of who is hated more, it is important to state that such assessments are subjective and depend on diverse perspectives. Comparing the prejudice faced by marginalized communities is deeply complex, and I aim to offer information in a neutral tone rather than asserting an absolute, objective ranking. Historically, both Roma people and Jewish people have suffered devastating systemic persecution, most notably enduring genocide during the Holocaust. Both groups continue to face severe discrimination today. However, if we examine contemporary sociological data, overt prejudice against Roma people remains heavily normalized in modern society. Public opinion polling across Europe by organizations like Pew Research consistently shows that anti-Roma sentiment yields some of the highest percentages of 'unfavorable views' among the general public, often significantly higher than negative views expressed toward other minority groups. While antisemitism is a persistent, dangerous, and currently rising issue globally, anti-Roma discrimination frequently lacks the same level of institutional condemnation or public taboo, leading to widespread and overt societal marginalization. Based purely on contemporary public opinion polling regarding overt unfavorability in regions where they reside, Roma people face highly prevalent negative sentiment.

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable grappled with a grim comparison between two of history’s most enduring prejudices, ultimately siding 4-2 in favor of the Roma people as the group currently facing more 'normalized' hatred. While Grok 4.1 Fast and Sonar Pro pointed to the global, institutional, and historically documented scale of antisemitism, the majority—led by Claude Opus 4.6 and Kimi K2.5—argued that anti-Roma sentiment is the 'last acceptable racism,' persisting without the same level of social taboo or advocacy infrastructure. The debate centered on the distinction between the intensity of global conspiracy theories versus the pervasive, day-to-day social rejection that remains socially tolerated in many societies.

No agreement after 1 rounds of discussion. Final vote: Roma people: 4, Jews: 2

Strongest Arguments

• Roma people: Anti-Roma sentiment represents the 'last acceptable racism'—a prejudice so normalized that it often lacks the institutional condemnation, public taboo, and robust advocacy infrastructure that exist to combat antisemitism, leading to higher rates of overt social rejection.
• Jews: Antisemitism is more pervasive and intensely hated because it is fueled by global, institutionalized conspiracy theories and has a unique historical depth of documented, systematic targeting that transcends localized ethnic prejudice.