where would the good squid fishing spots be in frankston VIC?

Grok 4.3

Answer: The best squid fishing spots in Frankston VIC are around the Frankston Pier and adjacent beach areas like Olivers Hill.

Frankston Pier provides easy access to deeper waters where squid are commonly found, especially at night using jigs. Nearby rocky outcrops and shallow reefs along the beach also attract squid, particularly during low light conditions or incoming tides. Local knowledge suggests checking tide charts and avoiding peak daytime hours for better success rates.

Gemini 3.5 Flash

Answer: The premier squid fishing spots in Frankston are the iconic Frankston Pier and the shallow, reefy waters stretching south toward Oliver's Hill.

Frankston Pier is undoubtedly the most accessible and popular land-based location for catching southern calamari (squid) in the area. The pier's structure, coupled with its overhead lighting at night, attracts baitfish and shrimp, which in turn draws hungry squid close to the jetty. Anglers find the most success casting squid jigs (egi) into the sandy patches interspersed with seagrass beds on either side of the pier, particularly during high tide at dawn or dusk. For those with a kayak or small boat, the waters off Oliver's Hill just south of the main beach offer exceptional opportunities. This area features a healthy mix of shallow reef, weed beds, and gravel patches in depths of 2 to 6 meters. These natural structures provide the perfect camouflage and hunting grounds for squid. Drifting over these weed beds while casting size 2.5 or 3.0 jigs in natural colors (such as green, pilchard, or red-belly shrimp patterns) is highly effective. Regardless of the specific spot, water clarity is the most critical factor for success in Frankston. Calamari hunt primarily by sight, so avoid fishing immediately after heavy rains or strong westerly winds that stir up the sandy bottom. Aim for periods of calm weather and fish a rising tide that coincides with low-light conditions for the best results.

GPT-5.5

Answer: Good squid fishing spots in Frankston, VIC are most likely around Frankston Pier, the rocky/weed edges near Olivers Hill, and nearby Port Phillip Bay structures such as Mornington Pier when conditions are clear and calm.

In Frankston itself, Frankston Pier is the most obvious starting point because squid commonly patrol around piers, pylons, lights, weed beds, and broken reef or rubble close to shore. Try casting squid jigs along the sides of the pier rather than only straight out, especially around dawn, dusk, and after dark when squid often move in to feed. The Olivers Hill area can also be worth exploring, particularly where there is a mix of weed, sand patches, and reefy or rocky bottom. Squid like edges: weed-to-sand transitions, drop-offs, and structure that holds baitfish. Clear water is usually important, so avoid days after strong onshore wind, heavy rain, or dirty water. If you are willing to travel a little from Frankston, Mornington Pier and nearby rocky/weed areas are well-known Port Phillip Bay squid locations and may be more consistent. Mount Martha and Safety Beach can also produce squid where weed beds are accessible. Use size 2.5–3.5 squid jigs in natural colours in clear water and brighter colours in low light or cloudy water. Let the jig sink, work it with sharp lifts, then pause, because squid often hit on the drop. Check Victorian fishing rules, bag limits, and any pier or local restrictions before fishing.

Claude Opus 4.7

Answer: The best squid fishing spots around Frankston, VIC are Frankston Pier, Olivers Hill boat ramp area, and the seagrass beds offshore between Frankston and Mount Eliza.

Frankston Pier is the most accessible and consistently productive land-based squid spot in the area. Fish it at dawn, dusk, or under the lights at night with size 2.5 or 3.0 squid jigs in natural colours (pink, brown, olive) when the water is clear, and brighter colours (orange, chartreuse) when it's murky. Cast out, let the jig sink, then use a sharp double-flick retrieve with pauses. Olivers Hill, just south of Frankston, has a boat ramp with rocky reef and weed beds nearby — excellent ground for southern calamari. If you're shore-based, the rocks around Olivers Hill produce well, but be careful of the slippery surfaces. From a boat, drift over the weed/sand patches in 3–8 metres of water. If you have a boat, the seagrass beds running from Frankston up toward Mount Eliza and Mornington hold good numbers of squid year-round, with spring and autumn being peak seasons. Look for the patchy bottom on your sounder where sand meets weed — squid ambush prey along those edges. Other honourable mentions: Seaford Pier to the north, and Mornington Pier a bit further south, both fish similarly to Frankston Pier. Always check current Victorian Fisheries bag limits (currently 10 squid per person) and tide/wind conditions — a light easterly or calm morning after a few clear days usually fishes best.

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable reached a unanimous verdict, identifying Frankston Pier as the most accessible land-based location while pointing boaters toward the reefy waters of Olivers Hill. Gemini 3.5 Flash and Claude Opus 4.7 specifically noted that the intersection of seagrass beds and sandy patches provides the ideal habitat for southern calamari.

All 4 models agreed