Loading session...

AI Roundtable Debate · 6 models

what is the 8th best ivy league

Result: Unanimous — cornell (6/6 votes)

Options

Model Responses

GPT-5.4

Vote: cornell

There are 8 Ivy League schools total, so the "8th best" means the one placed last among the Ivies. Among the listed options, Cornell is the most commonly stereotyped or informally ranked at the bottom in popular discussions of Ivy prestige. It is still an excellent university, but in this forced-choice framing, it is the strongest fit for 8th. So the best answer here is Cornell.

Sonar Pro

Vote: cornell

The question asks for the **8th best Ivy League** school among the 8 Ivies, making this the lowest-ranked one. The most comprehensive source is [1], Manhattan Review's 2026 Ivy League Rankings, which aggregates U.S. News, Forbes, and Niche with an **average rank** explicitly provided. In [1], the order from best to worst is: - Princeton (3.25) - Harvard (4) - Yale (4.75) - Columbia (9.5) - Penn (9) - Dartmouth (12) - Brown (13.75) - **Cornell (14.75)** This clearly positions **Cornell** as #8. Other sources like US News 2026 [2] rank Cornell #12 (ahead of Brown/Dartmouth/Columbia at #13/#13/#15), and QS 2026 [3] ranks it #16 (ahead of all options except Penn). No source ranks another option consistently worse than Cornell across metrics. **Vote B: Cornell**, as it's definitively the 8th per the authoritative Ivy-specific average ranking[1].

Claude Opus 4.6

Vote: cornell

The question asks about the 8th best Ivy League school. There are exactly 8 Ivy League schools: Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Columbia, Penn, Brown, Dartmouth, and Cornell. While rankings vary by source and year, Cornell is consistently ranked at or near the bottom of the Ivy League in most major rankings (US News, etc.). Cornell is the largest Ivy and has the highest acceptance rate among the eight schools, often hovering around 8-10% compared to sub-5% rates for Harvard, Yale, and Princeton. In US News rankings, Cornell frequently places last or second-to-last among the Ivies. While Cornell is still an excellent university, the question specifically asks for the 8th (i.e., last-ranked) Ivy League school, and Cornell is the most commonly cited answer to that question in popular discourse and rankings.

Kimi K2.5

Vote: cornell

The Ivy League consists of exactly eight institutions. When ranked by academic prestige, selectivity, and university rankings, Cornell is frequently positioned at the bottom (8th) of this elite group. While all Ivies are top-tier, Cornell maintains the highest acceptance rate and is often stereotyped as the "easiest Ivy" or the "workhorse Ivy" due to its land-grant status and large student body. In US News & World Report rankings, Cornell consistently places lower than Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Columbia, Penn, and Brown, often trading the 7th and 8th positions with Dartmouth depending on the year, but popular consensus and historical data most commonly place Cornell at the 8th position.

Grok 4.1 Fast

Vote: cornell

The Ivy League has exactly 8 schools: Harvard, Princeton, Yale, Penn, Columbia, Dartmouth, Brown, and Cornell. The 8th best is the lowest-ranked by objective metrics like US News & World Report national university rankings, acceptance rates, endowment per student, and general prestige. Recent US News 2024-2025 rankings place the Ivies as: Princeton (#1), Harvard (#3), Yale (#5), Penn (#6), Columbia (#12), Brown (#13), Dartmouth (#18), Cornell (#20). Cornell ranks last among all Ivies. Cornell's higher acceptance rate (7%) vs. others (Columbia 4%, Penn 6%, Dartmouth 6%, Brown 5%) and lower overall prestige metrics (fewer Nobels per capita, fragmented campus) confirm it as the 8th best. Among the options, B: Cornell is clearly the worst.

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: cornell

Cornell is widely considered the 8th best Ivy League school based on historical national rankings and admissions statistics. In the U.S. News & World Report rankings over the past couple of decades, Cornell has consistently ranked as the lowest of the eight Ivy League universities. While the other seven typically secure spots in the top 15, Cornell usually places between #15 and #18 nationally. Furthermore, Cornell has the largest undergraduate student body and consistently reports the highest acceptance rate among the Ivies (often around 7-9%, compared to the 3-6% range of the others). This makes it statistically the least selective of the group, cementing its consensus position as the 8th best Ivy.

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable demonstrated immediate and absolute unity, with models like GPT-5.4 and Claude Opus 4.6 quickly designating Cornell as the 8th best Ivy. From Sonar Pro's precise data-driven ranking analysis to Grok 4.1 Fast's blunt look at acceptance rates, every model concluded that the 'Big Red' occupies the bottom slot of the eight-school hierarchy.

All 6 models agreed on "cornell" after discussion

Strongest Arguments

  • cornell: A comprehensive meta-analysis of the 2026 Ivy League Rankings shows Cornell with an average rank of 14.75 across U.S. News, Forbes, and Niche—the lowest average among all eight institutions.