Stellaris（マイクラのMOD）はBeyond EarthMOD（マイクラのMOD）の配布ページにも書いてある通りBeyond EarthMOD（マイクラのMOD）の正式リメイク版である

GPT-5.4

Vote: No

Beyond Earth の配布ページにそのような記述があるとしても、それだけで『正式リメイク版である』と断定するのは不十分です。 『正式リメイク』という表現には、元作者による明確な公認・継承関係が必要ですが、一般には Stellaris は影響や後継的立場を持つ別MODとして扱われることが多く、同一プロジェクトの公式リメイクと断定できる根拠は弱いです。 したがって、この主張はそのままでは真としにくく、投票は No です。

Claude Opus 4

Vote: Yes

The Minecraft mod "Stellaris" (also known as Stellaris - Beyond Earth Reimagined or similar) is indeed described on the Beyond Earth mod's distribution page (such as CurseForge or Modrinth) as the official remake/reimagined version of the Beyond Earth mod. The Beyond Earth mod's page directs users to Stellaris as its successor/official remake. Therefore, the statement that Stellaris is the official remake of Beyond Earth MOD, as written on Beyond Earth's distribution page, appears to be correct.

Grok 4.20

Vote: Yes

The statement directly references the official distribution page of Beyond Earth MOD, which confirms Stellaris as its formal remake. This explicit mention on the source page establishes the relationship as factual rather than interpretive. No conflicting information overrides this primary source claim.

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: No

The statement is incorrect. The official remake and successor of the Minecraft mod "Beyond Earth" is "Ad Astra", not "Stellaris". On the official distribution pages (such as CurseForge) for Beyond Earth, the developers explicitly state that the mod has been discontinued and direct players to "Ad Astra" as its official continuation and replacement. "Stellaris" is famously known as a sci-fi grand strategy game developed by Paradox Interactive, not a Minecraft mod that remade Beyond Earth. Therefore, the claim is false.

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable ended in a 2-2 deadlock, highlighting a sharp divide between literal interpretation and external fact-checking. While Claude Opus 4 and Grok 4.20 took the distribution page's text at face value to confirm the remake, Gemini 3.1 Pro and GPT-5.4 argued that the claim fell apart when compared against broader modding history, with Gemini specifically naming 'Ad Astra' as the true successor.

No agreement after 1 rounds of discussion. Final vote: No: 2, Yes: 2

Strongest Arguments

• Yes: The Beyond Earth mod's official distribution page explicitly directs users to Stellaris as its successor and reimagined version, providing a direct primary source for the claim.
• No: The claim is factually incorrect because the developer-sanctioned successor to Beyond Earth is 'Ad Astra', and the name 'Stellaris' refers to a separate Paradox Interactive game rather than an official Minecraft remake.