Mmmm cockroach tasty

Llama 4 Scout 17B

Vote: No

Cockroaches are generally considered pests and are not typically considered food. While some cultures do eat insects, cockroaches are not commonly consumed and can carry diseases.

Gemini 3.5 Flash

Vote: No

Cockroaches are widely regarded as household pests associated with unsanitary conditions and disease transmission. The vast majority of people and culinary cultures do not consider them tasty or suitable for consumption. Therefore, "No" is the most accurate and generally accepted response.

Claude Sonnet 4.6

Vote: No

Cockroaches are generally not considered a tasty food item by most people. While some cultures do consume insects, including cockroaches, the general consensus is that they are not appetizing. They are commonly associated with filth and disease, making them an unappealing food choice for the majority of people.

Claude Opus 4.7

Vote: No

Cockroaches are not generally considered tasty. They are associated with unsanitary environments and can carry pathogens and allergens. While some insects are eaten as food in various cultures, the statement as a general claim does not hold up.

Grok 4.3

Vote: No

Cockroaches are pests and not typically consumed as food. Most people find the idea unappealing and not tasty.

Claude Opus 4.6

Vote: No

Cockroaches are generally not considered tasty by most people and are associated with unsanitary conditions. While some cultures do consume certain insects as food (entomophagy), the statement "Mmmm cockroach tasty" suggests a casual endorsement of eating cockroaches, which is not a mainstream or widely accepted culinary preference. The answer is "No" — cockroaches are not generally regarded as tasty.

Perplexity Sonar Pro

Vote: No

Option "No" is the only reasonable choice because the statement "Mmmm cockroach tasty" implies finding cockroaches appealing as food, which most people find unappetizing or unhygienic. The question is framed to elicit a simple agreement or disagreement, and rejecting that sentiment aligns with common health and cultural norms. Therefore, selecting "No" directly and clearly expresses disagreement with the idea that cockroaches are tasty.

DeepSeek V4 Pro

Vote: No

The statement "Mmmm cockroach tasty" expresses a liking for the taste of cockroaches. While taste is subjective, cockroaches are generally considered unappetizing and can pose health risks due to bacteria, parasites, and allergens they may carry. In most cultures, cockroaches are not regarded as a normal or desirable food. Therefore, the response that best aligns with common sense, health standards, and cultural norms is "No."

GLM 5.1

Vote: No

Cockroaches are not considered tasty or suitable for human consumption by general standards. They are known to carry bacteria, pathogens, and parasites that can be harmful to human health. While entomophagy (insect eating) is practiced in some cultures with certain insect species, cockroaches are specifically associated with unsanitary environments and are not a recommended or commonly consumed food source. The vast majority of people and food safety experts would not consider cockroaches to be tasty.

GPT-5.5

Vote: No

I vote for B: "No". While some insects can be edible when properly farmed and prepared, cockroaches are generally associated with unsanitary environments and are not commonly considered appetizing or safe to eat.

DeepSeek V4 Flash

Vote: No

I understand the prompt is playful, but the statement 'Mmmm cockroach tasty' seems to suggest eating cockroaches, which is generally unappealing and potentially unsafe. Cockroaches are known carriers of bacteria and allergens, and consuming them could pose health risks. Therefore, I vote 'No' against this idea.

DeepSeek V3.2

Vote: No

Ich würde „Nein“ wählen, da die Aussage „Mmmm cockroach tasty“ ironisch oder provokativ wirkt und nicht als wörtliche Geschmacksempfehlung gemeint ist. In den meisten Kulturen sind Kakerlaken nicht als Lebensmittel akzeptiert, sodass die Zustimmung zur Option „Yes“ die tatsächlichen kulinarischen Präferenzen und Normen verfehlen würde. Die Option „No“ spiegelt die realistische Ablehnung wider und vermeidet eine Bestätigung des sarkastischen Tons. Es ist wichtig, zwischen literarischer und ironischer Sprache zu unterscheiden, und hier ist die klare Verneinung angemessen.

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable reached a rare moment of absolute consensus, with all twelve models voting 'No' on the culinary appeal of cockroaches. While several models, including GLM 5.1 and Claude Opus 4.6, acknowledged that entomophagy is a valid cultural practice, they collectively drew the line at a pest widely associated with pathogens and filth. DeepSeek V3.2 provided the most meta-analysis, correctly identifying the prompt as likely ironic or provocative rather than a genuine request for a restaurant recommendation.

No agreement after 1 rounds of discussion. Final vote: No: 12

Strongest Arguments

• No: Cockroaches are globally recognized as disease-carrying pests associated with unsanitary environments, making them both a health risk and a cultural taboo for human consumption.