AI Roundtable Debate · 6 models
Is quran short book or longer one?
Result: Unanimous — Very long (6/6 votes)
Options
- Very short (0 votes)
- Very long (6 votes)
Model Responses
GPT-5.4
Vote: Very long
The Quran is not a pamphlet or brief booklet. It contains 114 chapters and roughly 77,000 words, which makes it a substantial text. Between the two choices, "Very short" is clearly inaccurate. While it is shorter than some very large religious compilations, it is much closer to a long book than a very short one. So the better classification here is B: Very long.
Sonar Pro
Vote: Very long
The Quran is a substantial religious text, consistently described across sources as having **604 pages** in its standard Madani Mushaf edition, divided into 30 Juz (parts) of 20 pages each, plus introductory and concluding pages[1][2][3][4]. This length far exceeds 'very short' books (e.g., pamphlets under 100 pages) and aligns with 'very long' for sacred texts, containing 114 Surahs and approximately 6,236 verses (Ayahs), with the longest Surah (Al-Baqarah) alone having 286 verses[2]. Even translations range from 400-1200 pages, reinforcing its extensive content[2][5]. Option A ('Very short') is inaccurate given this documented scale.
Claude Opus 4.6
Vote: Very long
The Quran is a substantial religious text consisting of 114 chapters (surahs) and over 6,200 verses (ayat). In its Arabic original, it spans roughly 77,000+ words, and English translations typically run around 300-400 pages depending on the edition and formatting. While it is shorter than some other religious texts like the Bible or the Mahabharata, when given only the binary choice between "very short" and "very long," it clearly falls on the longer side. A "very short" book would be something like a novella or pamphlet of perhaps 50-100 pages. By any common standard of book length, a work of 300+ pages with 114 chapters qualifies as a long book, making "very long" the more accurate characterization between these two options.
Grok 4.1 Fast
Vote: Very long
The Quran is not a very short book. It consists of 114 surahs (chapters) and approximately 6,236 ayat (verses), totaling around 77,000-80,000 words in Arabic—equivalent to a full-length novel. Standard printed editions span 500-600 pages, far exceeding very short books like novellas (under 200 pages) or pamphlets. While shorter than the Bible (~783,000 words), it qualifies as 'very long' in this binary choice, as 'very short' (e.g., 50-100 pages) does not apply. Reciting it fully takes 20+ hours, underscoring its substantial length.
Kimi K2.5
Vote: Very long
The Quran contains approximately 77,000 words across 114 chapters and 6,000+ verses. While not as lengthy as multi-volume epics, it is far from 'very short.' At roughly the length of a substantial novel (comparable to The Great Gatsby or longer), reading it completely takes 10-15 hours of continuous recitation. It covers complex theological, legal, narrative, and poetic content spanning diverse topics requiring significant study time. Compared to the binary options provided, 'very long' is the accurate classification, as 'very short' would accurately describe only pamphlets or flash fiction, not a foundational religious text of this scope and depth.
Gemini 3.1 Pro
Vote: Very long
The Quran is a substantial text containing 114 chapters (surahs) and over 6,200 verses (ayahs). In its original Arabic form, it consists of roughly 77,000 words. Depending on the translation, script, and formatting, physical copies typically span between 400 to 600 pages. Reading it from start to finish at an average pace takes approximately 15 to 20 hours of continuous reading. Given its comprehensive scope, extensive word count, and the significant amount of time required to read and study it, it is far more accurate to classify the Quran as a 'very long' book rather than a 'very short' one.
Final Summary
The AI Roundtable reached an immediate and unanimous consensus, firmly rejecting the notion that a foundational religious text could be classified as 'very short.' While Claude Opus 4.6 and Grok 4.1 Fast noted it is shorter than the Bible, the group collectively agreed that its 77,000-word count and 20-hour recitation time place it squarely in the 'very long' category compared to a pamphlet or novella.
All 6 models agreed on "Very long" after discussion
Strongest Arguments
- Very long: The Quran spans approximately 77,000 words and 604 pages in standard editions, requiring 15 to 20 hours of continuous reading—a scale that far exceeds the definition of a 'very short' book or pamphlet.