Is my flatmate ignorant for using her phone scrolling tiktoks without headphones when the kitchen is right next to my door and i cant concentrate on work hearing sounds? we rent a room in the apartment, so i thought she would just go to her room and scroll there if she wants that and not use our super small apartments kitchen as some sort of lounge zone or am i overreactive. Keep in mind i told her before to please use headphones and that the apartment is small and my door faces the kitchen. the apartment is just a small corridor connected with a small kitchen. then her room to the left and mine to the right.

GPT-5.4

Vote: Yes

Yes — in this setup, her behavior is inconsiderate. The key issue is not that she uses the kitchen or watches TikToks. It’s that she plays audio out loud in a very small shared space directly next to your door, knowing it disrupts your ability to work. You also already communicated the problem and asked her to use headphones. Once someone has been clearly told that their noise is bothering a flatmate, continuing to do it is no longer innocent obliviousness — it becomes rude and dismissive. She does have reasonable alternatives: headphones, lower volume, or using her own room. In a tiny apartment, shared-space noise etiquette matters more, not less. You are not overreactive for wanting basic quiet while working. The stronger claim is not that she can never be in the kitchen, but that using speakers for casual scrolling there after being asked not to is inconsiderate.

Grok 4.1 Fast

Vote: Yes

The flatmate is ignorant (inconsiderate) because the apartment is extremely small, with the kitchen directly adjacent to the user's door, making noise unavoidable and disruptive to work concentration. She was explicitly told once before to use headphones due to this layout, yet continues the behavior, showing disregard for the shared space dynamics and the user's needs. Kitchens are for practical use, but treating it as a 'lounge zone' for loud TikTok scrolling ignores basic roommate courtesy, especially after a polite request. The user is not overreacting—reasonable accommodation in tight quarters is expected.

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: Yes

Your flatmate is definitely being inconsiderate (ignorant to your needs) in this situation. When living in a very small shared apartment, basic etiquette requires being mindful of noise levels, especially since sound travels easily through thin walls and close corridors. The most critical factor here is that you have already communicated your needs. You politely asked her to use headphones and explained that your door faces the kitchen. By choosing to ignore a reasonable request, she is showing a lack of respect for your boundaries and your ability to work comfortably in your own home. Furthermore, she has easy alternatives. She could simply put on headphones or move to her private room to scroll through TikTok. Asking someone to manage their digital audio in a shared, confined space is a standard and expected compromise in any roommate arrangement. You are not overreacting; you are asking for basic common courtesy.

Claude Opus 4.6

Vote: Yes

Yes, your flatmate is being inconsiderate. There are several clear reasons why: 1. **You've already communicated the issue.** This isn't a case where she might not know it bothers you — you've explicitly asked her to use headphones. Continuing the behavior after being asked to stop is the definition of being inconsiderate/ignorant of your needs. 2. **The apartment layout makes this unavoidable.** Your door faces directly into the kitchen in a small corridor apartment. There's no way for you to escape the noise without her cooperation. She has the simple option of using headphones or going to her own room. 3. **Using headphones is an extremely low-effort solution.** You're not asking her to stop watching TikToks entirely or to never use the kitchen. You're asking for a basic courtesy — headphones — that costs her virtually nothing. 4. **Shared spaces require mutual respect.** In a small shared apartment, common areas like the kitchen should be used for their intended purpose (cooking, eating), not as a personal lounge for playing audio out loud, especially when it directly impacts a flatmate's ability to work. 5. **You are not being overreactive.** Being unable to concentrate on work due to avoidable noise in a shared living situation is a legitimate concern, and your request is perfectly reasonable.

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable reached a swift and unanimous verdict: the flatmate's behavior is undeniably inconsiderate. Models like Claude Opus 4.6 and GPT-5.4 emphasized that because a request for headphones had already been made, her continued scrolling moved beyond 'obliviousness' and into the realm of being dismissive of a shared living environment.

All 4 models agreed on "Yes" after discussion

Strongest Arguments

• Yes: Once a resident has been explicitly informed that their noise is disruptive in a confined shared space, continuing the behavior is no longer innocent obliviousness—it becomes a rude and dismissive disregard for a flatmate's boundaries.