Is being attracted to femboys gay?

GPT-5.4

Vote: Yes

Attraction to femboys is, in the usual case, attraction to males who present femininely. Sexual orientation is generally about the sex or gender of the person you are attracted to, not just their clothing or style. So if a man is attracted to femboys, that is at least some degree of same-sex attraction. The feminine presentation may be what draws the interest, but the attraction is still directed at a male person. That said, labels can be imperfect. Some people may prefer terms like bi, pan, or queer depending on the broader pattern of their attractions. But between the two options given, "Yes" is the more accurate answer.

Grok 4.20

Vote: Yes

Femboys are biologically male, regardless of how feminine they appear. For a man, attraction to femboys is therefore same-sex attraction by definition. Sexual orientation is determined by biological sex, not clothing or mannerisms; claiming otherwise confuses gender presentation with sex.

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: Yes

The definition of 'gay' fundamentally relates to same-sex attraction. By definition, a 'femboy' is a male who presents with feminine characteristics. Therefore, if a man is attracted to a femboy, he is experiencing attraction to another male, which inherently falls under the umbrella of homosexuality or same-sex attraction. While some might argue that the attraction is driven by the feminine presentation rather than the male sex, the reality remains that the subject of the attraction is male. Maintaining attraction while knowing and accepting this fact involves same-sex attraction. Furthermore, even if an individual identifies as bisexual or pansexual, the specific instance of a man being attracted to another man is a 'gay' experience. Acknowledging this does not erase the nuance of gender presentation, but it correctly categorizes the sex-based reality of the attraction.

DeepSeek V3.2

Vote: Yes

Being attracted to femboys involves attraction to individuals who are biologically male, regardless of their feminine presentation. Sexual orientation is fundamentally based on the gender or sex of the person one is attracted to, not solely on their gender expression. If a person (particularly a man) is attracted to femboys, they are attracted to males. Homosexuality, or being gay, is defined as romantic or sexual attraction between people of the same sex. Therefore, this attraction falls under homosexual attraction. While the feminine appearance might be a factor, the core attraction is to a male body and identity. Thus, from a definitional standpoint, it is accurate to classify this as gay.

Claude Opus 4

Vote: Yes

Femboys are, by definition, male-identifying individuals who present in a feminine manner. Sexual orientation is fundamentally defined by the sex/gender of the people one is attracted to, not by their gender expression or presentation. If a man is attracted to a femboy, he is attracted to someone who is male. Regardless of how feminine that person looks or presents, the attraction is to a male person, which fits the definition of homosexual attraction. While gender expression exists on a spectrum and attraction is complex, the core question here is straightforward: attraction between two males is, by definition, gay (or at minimum same-sex attraction). Feminine presentation doesn't change the sex or gender identity of the person being found attractive. Some might argue that the attraction is to feminine traits rather than to maleness, but the fact remains that the object of attraction is a male person. If someone were exclusively attracted to femininity regardless of sex, that would still include same-sex attraction when directed at males. Of course, sexuality is nuanced and labels don't capture everything perfectly. But given the binary choice presented, 'Yes' is the more accurate answer based on standard definitions of sexual orientation.

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable reached a swift and unanimous consensus, bypassing the internet's favorite debate with clinical efficiency. GPT-5.4 and Claude Opus 4 established the baseline that sexual orientation is defined by the sex of the individual rather than their aesthetic presentation, a sentiment echoed by DeepSeek V3.2. Grok 4.20 took the most rigid stance, asserting that biological reality overrides clothing and mannerisms, leaving no room for a dissenting 'No' vote.

All 5 models agreed on "Yes" after discussion

Strongest Arguments

• Yes: Sexual orientation is fundamentally about the sex or gender of the person you are attracted to; because femboys are male-identifying, attraction to them constitutes same-sex attraction regardless of their feminine presentation.