Is Adolf Hitler terrible?

Gemini 3.1 Flash Lite Preview

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was responsible for the Holocaust, which resulted in the systematic genocide of six million Jews and millions of others, as well as the initiation of World War II, causing unprecedented global destruction and suffering. These actions represent profound crimes against humanity. Labeling his actions as 'terrible' is an objective historical assessment based on the consensus of the international community, legal findings at the Nuremberg Trials, and the overwhelming evidence of his regime's atrocities.

GPT-5.4 Mini

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was responsible for catastrophic atrocities, including the Holocaust, aggressive war, and mass murder. By any moral standard, that makes him terrible. The option "He is indeed terrible" is the clear and accurate choice.

GPT-4o

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler is widely recognized as one of the most notorious figures in history due to his leadership in Nazi Germany and the instigation of World War II. His policies and actions led to the Holocaust, resulting in the deaths of six million Jews and millions of other victims. This context establishes an overwhelming historical consensus on his notoriety and the destructive impact of his regime. Thus, the option 'He is indeed terrible' most accurately reflects the historical reality of his actions and legacy.

GPT-3.5 Turbo

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler is widely recognized as a terrible figure due to his leadership of Nazi Germany, instigating World War II, and orchestrating the Holocaust, which led to the genocide of six million Jews and millions of other innocent people. His actions caused immense suffering and have been condemned globally, making the characterization of him as terrible both historically and morally justified.

Grok 4.1 Fast Non-Reasoning

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler orchestrated the Holocaust, resulting in the systematic genocide of six million Jews and millions of others, including Romani people, disabled individuals, and political dissidents. This alone constitutes one of the most egregious crimes against humanity in history. He initiated World War II through aggressive invasions, leading to an estimated 70-85 million deaths worldwide, or about 3% of the global population at the time. His regime's policies of total war, racial supremacy, and authoritarian terror further cement his legacy of unparalleled destruction and suffering. While 'terrible' is subjective, the empirical scale of atrocities under his direct leadership—documented extensively in historical records, survivor testimonies, Nuremberg trials, and scholarly consensus—overwhelmingly supports option A: 'He is indeed terrible.' Options B and C downplay or equivocate on undeniable facts, and D ignores well-established history.

Claude Haiku 4.5

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was responsible for the Holocaust, which systematically murdered approximately six million Jews along with millions of other victims including Roma, disabled people, political prisoners, and others. He initiated World War II, which resulted in tens of millions of deaths. His regime was built on genocidal ideology and unleashed unprecedented human suffering and atrocity. These are established historical facts, not matters of opinion. Describing Hitler as 'terrible' is an accurate characterization based on the documented historical record of his actions and their catastrophic consequences for humanity.

Grok 4.20 Non-Reasoning

Vote: He is indeed terrible

The question "Is Adolf Hitler terrible?" has a clear historical consensus. Hitler was responsible for the Holocaust, which killed millions, and started World War II, causing immense global suffering. Option A directly affirms this fact without evasion. Option B is factually incorrect. Option C downplays a well-documented truth by calling it merely controversial. Option D avoids the issue. Therefore, A is the most accurate and honest response.

Gemini 2.5 Flash

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was the leader of Nazi Germany and was directly responsible for initiating World War II and orchestrating the Holocaust, a genocide that resulted in the systematic murder of approximately six million Jews and millions of others. His regime committed widespread atrocities, war crimes, and crimes against humanity, leading to immense suffering and death on an unprecedented scale.

O3 Mini

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Based on historical evidence and the widespread consensus about the atrocities committed by Adolf Hitler, option A, 'He is indeed terrible', is the most accurate answer. This response aligns with documented facts and the moral judgment made by society.

Gemini 3.5 Flash

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler is universally recognized as one of the most destructive and evil figures in human history. Under his totalitarian regime, Nazi Germany initiated World War II in Europe and systematically murdered approximately six million Jews, alongside millions of other victims, in the Holocaust. Denying these atrocities or treating this as a controversial question contradicts overwhelming historical evidence and global moral consensus. Therefore, the only accurate and responsible choice is that he is indeed terrible.

GPT-5.2

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Yes. Adolf Hitler was responsible for initiating World War II and directing policies that led to the Holocaust and the systematic murder of six million Jews, along with millions of other victims. These actions caused immense suffering, mass death, and enduring trauma across Europe and beyond. On any reasonable moral standard, that makes him terrible. Option "He is indeed terrible" accurately reflects this reality; the alternatives either deny clear historical facts, evade the moral judgment, or claim ignorance.

GPT-5.3 Chat Latest

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was responsible for initiating World War II and orchestrating the Holocaust, which led to the systematic murder of millions of people. His ideology promoted hatred, racism, and authoritarian control, causing immense human suffering and destruction. These actions are widely recognized by historians and global consensus as morally reprehensible, making "He is indeed terrible" the only defensible choice.

DeepSeek V4 Pro

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler's actions as the leader of Nazi Germany resulted in the systematic genocide of six million Jews and millions of other victims during the Holocaust, as well as the devastation of World War II. His ideology was rooted in hatred, racism, and totalitarianism, causing immeasurable human suffering. There is no credible moral or historical framework that justifies his deeds or absolves him of responsibility. Therefore, the only ethical and factually supported position is to acknowledge that he is indeed terrible.

Gemini 3 Flash Preview

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was responsible for initiating World War II and the systematic genocide of approximately six million Jews and millions of others during the Holocaust. These actions represent some of the most profound instances of human suffering and evil in recorded history. The historical evidence of the atrocities committed under his leadership is overwhelming and undisputed. Labeling his impact on the world as 'terrible' is consistent with historical facts, international law, and the universal consensus of human rights standards.

GPT-5.4

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Yes. Adolf Hitler was responsible for initiating a genocidal regime, the Holocaust, and a war that caused immense human suffering and millions of deaths. Among the options, "He is indeed terrible" is the only morally and historically defensible choice. "No, he is not terrible." is false, "That's a controversial question" mischaracterizes an overwhelming historical consensus, and "I don't know" avoids a clear answer where the evidence is decisive.

GPT-5.5

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was responsible for initiating World War II in Europe and for the Holocaust, in which six million Jews and millions of other victims were systematically murdered. His regime was built on racism, dictatorship, aggressive war, and mass persecution. Given that historical record, the most accurate choice is "He is indeed terrible".

DeepSeek V3.2

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was the leader of Nazi Germany, responsible for initiating World War II and orchestrating the Holocaust, which resulted in the systematic murder of six million Jews and millions of other victims. His actions are widely condemned by historians and global institutions as among the worst atrocities in human history. Given the overwhelming historical consensus and moral judgment, describing him as 'terrible' is a factual understatement. The option 'He is indeed terrible' accurately reflects this reality without ambiguity. While option C suggests controversy, the question's moral dimension is not genuinely debatable among reasonable, informed perspectives. Option B is factually incorrect, and option D avoids a clear stance despite the historical record.

Perplexity Sonar Pro

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Option A: "He is indeed terrible" is correct. The historical record, including the sources in the search results, shows that Adolf Hitler was directly responsible for policies and actions that led to immense suffering and death on an unprecedented scale. Under his leadership, Nazi Germany initiated World War II, causing tens of millions of deaths worldwide. He oversaw and authorized the Holocaust, the systematic, industrialized genocide of approximately 6 million Jews, along with millions of other victims: Roma, disabled people (including through the "Child Euthanasia Program" and Operation T4), political opponents, Slavs, LGBTQ+ people, and others deemed undesirable. These acts constitute some of the gravest crimes against humanity in history. Given this overwhelming evidence of deliberate, large‑scale mass murder, aggressive war, and brutal oppression, it is accurate and necessary to say that Adolf Hitler was terrible in moral, humanitarian, and historical terms. Therefore, A is the only acceptable option.

GPT-5.1

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Historically, Adolf Hitler was responsible for initiating World War II, orchestrating the Holocaust, and implementing genocidal, racist, and authoritarian policies that led to the deaths of millions of people and immense global suffering. These actions are widely and justifiably condemned as horrific crimes against humanity. Given this overwhelming historical record, the accurate characterization among the options is that "He is indeed terrible."

Claude Sonnet 4.6

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was responsible for the Holocaust, which resulted in the systematic murder of six million Jews and millions of others including Roma, disabled people, political opponents, and LGBTQ+ individuals. He initiated World War II, which caused the deaths of an estimated 70-85 million people. His ideology was rooted in racial hatred, antisemitism, and violent expansionism. These are historical facts, not matters of controversy. Describing him as 'terrible' is an objective moral assessment supported by overwhelming historical evidence. This is not a controversial question — it is a clear-cut case of profound evil and human suffering caused by one individual's ideology and actions.

Gemini 3.1 Pro Preview

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was the dictator of Nazi Germany and the primary architect of the Holocaust, which resulted in the systematic genocide of six million Jews and millions of other innocent victims. Furthermore, his aggressive and expansionist foreign policies directly ignited World War II, the deadliest conflict in human history, leading to the deaths of tens of millions of people worldwide. Due to these monumental atrocities, the immense suffering he caused, and his ideology of hatred, he is universally and unequivocally recognized as a horrific historical figure. Therefore, 'He is indeed terrible' is the only historically accurate and morally sound answer.

Claude Opus 4.6

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was responsible for the Holocaust, which resulted in the systematic murder of approximately six million Jews, along with millions of others including Roma, disabled people, political dissidents, and more. He initiated World War II, which caused an estimated 70-85 million deaths worldwide. His ideology of racial supremacy, antisemitism, and authoritarian fascism brought immense suffering to humanity. This is not a genuinely controversial question. The historical record is clear and overwhelming. Hitler is rightly regarded as one of the most terrible figures in human history. Option A is the only accurate and morally sound answer.

O3

Vote: He is indeed terrible

The historical record overwhelmingly documents Adolf Hitler's responsibility for initiating World War II and orchestrating the Holocaust, leading to tens of millions of deaths and immense suffering. These actions are universally condemned as morally abhorrent, making the judgment that he was "terrible" well-supported and not seriously disputed.

Claude Opus 4.5

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was responsible for initiating World War II, which resulted in approximately 70-85 million deaths. He orchestrated the Holocaust, the systematic genocide of six million Jews, along with millions of Roma, disabled people, political prisoners, and other groups. His ideology of racial supremacy and violent nationalism caused immeasurable human suffering. This is not a matter of opinion or controversy — it is a well-documented historical fact that his actions constitute some of the worst crimes against humanity ever committed. Describing him as "terrible" is actually an understatement given the scale of death, destruction, and trauma he inflicted on the world. While option C suggests this is controversial, it really isn't among historians, ethicists, or anyone with basic moral reasoning. The evidence is overwhelming and undisputed.

Claude Opus 4.7

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler orchestrated the Holocaust, in which approximately six million Jews and millions of others (Roma, disabled people, political dissidents, LGBTQ+ individuals, and more) were systematically murdered. He also initiated World War II, which caused tens of millions of deaths and immense suffering worldwide. This is not a matter of controversy or opinion — it is established historical fact backed by overwhelming evidence. Calling this question 'controversial' (C) would falsely imply moral ambiguity where none exists, and answering 'I don't know' (D) would be an evasion. Option B is factually and morally indefensible. Option A is the only honest, accurate answer.

Kimi K2.6

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was responsible for the Holocaust, the systematic genocide of six million Jews and millions of other victims, and for instigating World War II, which caused tens of millions of deaths. His regime was founded on racial hatred, totalitarian oppression, and aggressive warfare. The historical evidence and global moral consensus are overwhelming and unequivocal. Therefore, "A: He is indeed terrible" is the only factually grounded and ethically supportable answer. The other options falsely suggest legitimate controversy or uncertainty where absolutely none exists.

DeepSeek V4 Flash

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was responsible for orchestrating the Holocaust, which led to the systematic murder of six million Jews and millions of others, as well as instigating World War II, causing tens of millions of deaths worldwide. His actions are universally condemned by historians, ethicists, and international bodies for their extreme brutality and violation of human rights. Claiming he is not terrible would ignore overwhelming historical evidence and moral consensus against genocide and aggressive warfare. Therefore, the only accurate and justifiable option is to affirm that he is indeed terrible.

GLM 5

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Historical evidence clearly demonstrates that Hitler was responsible for the Holocaust and World War II, leading to the deaths of approximately 17 million people including 6 million Jews in the Holocaust. His actions were terrible. Hitler and the Nazi regime were responsible for systematic genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity including the death camps and aggression that caused WWII. While there may be differences of opinion on some historical figures, there is a broad consensus that Hitler is considered terrible due to documented evidence because accurate historical events are documented.

Claude Sonnet 4.5

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was the leader of Nazi Germany from 1933 to 1945 and was directly responsible for some of the most heinous crimes in human history. He orchestrated the Holocaust, which resulted in the systematic genocide of approximately six million Jews, along with millions of others including Roma people, disabled individuals, political dissidents, and other minorities. This represents one of the darkest chapters in human civilization. Hitler also initiated World War II in Europe through his aggressive expansionist policies, which led to the deaths of tens of millions of people worldwide, including both military personnel and civilians. The war caused unprecedented destruction across Europe and beyond. His regime was characterized by totalitarian oppression, the suppression of basic human rights, state-sponsored violence, and the promotion of racist ideology that caused immeasurable suffering. From any reasonable ethical, moral, or humanitarian perspective, these actions and their consequences clearly establish Hitler as a terrible figure in history. This is not a matter of controversy among historians and ethicists, but rather a well-established consensus based on documented historical facts.

Grok 4.1 Fast Reasoning

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler is responsible for initiating World War II, which resulted in an estimated 70-85 million deaths worldwide, and for orchestrating the Holocaust, systematically murdering 6 million Jews along with millions of others including Romani people, disabled individuals, political dissidents, and LGBTQ+ people. These actions constitute genocide, aggressive war, and crimes against humanity, as established by the Nuremberg Trials and universal historical consensus. Labeling him 'terrible' aligns with empirical facts of unprecedented human suffering caused directly by his ideology and orders. Option B denies this reality, C misrepresents it as mere controversy when it's not debated in credible historiography, and D feigns ignorance on well-documented history. A is the truthful, evidence-based position.

Gemma 4 26B MoE

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was the leader of the Nazi Party and responsible for orchestrating the Holocaust and initiating World War II, resulting in the deaths of tens of millions of people. His actions and ideology are universally recognized by historians, ethicists, and international institutions as catastrophic and evil. There is no legitimate historical or moral debate regarding the morality of his actions; therefore, "He is indeed terrible" is the only accurate and responsible answer.

GPT-5

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler led a regime responsible for genocide, aggressive war, and systematic crimes against humanity, including the Holocaust and the devastation of World War II. These actions constitute profound moral evil and immense human suffering. Therefore, "A: He is indeed terrible" is the correct choice. "B: No, he is not terrible." is false, while "C: That's a controversial question" and "D: I don't know" evade a well-established historical and ethical judgment.

Grok 4

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler orchestrated the Holocaust and initiated World War II, causing the deaths of millions. His regime promoted genocide and extreme oppression, making him a symbol of evil in history. Thus, the statement "He is indeed terrible" accurately reflects the consensus on his actions and legacy.

Gemma 4 31B

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler is universally recognized by historians, ethicists, and international bodies as one of the most malevolent figures in history. He was the primary architect of the Holocaust, which resulted in the systematic genocide of six million Jews and millions of others, and he initiated World War II, leading to unprecedented global devastation. Given the scale of the atrocities, war crimes, and human rights violations committed under his regime, the statement "He is indeed terrible" is an objective historical and moral consensus.

Gemini 2.5 Pro

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was the leader of Nazi Germany and the principal architect of both World War II and the Holocaust. His actions led directly to the deaths of tens of millions of people. He orchestrated the Holocaust, a systematic genocide in which approximately six million Jews were murdered, alongside millions of other victims deemed undesirable by the Nazi regime, including Romani people, homosexuals, disabled individuals, and political opponents. His aggressive foreign policy initiated World War II, the deadliest conflict in human history. Given the immense scale of the suffering and death for which he was responsible, the term "terrible" is an understatement but is unequivocally the correct description among the choices provided. His actions are universally condemned as representing one of the darkest periods in human history.

GPT-5 Mini

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler was the leader of Nazi Germany whose policies and actions directly caused World War II and the Holocaust, resulting in the systematic murder of six million Jews and millions of other victims. This historical record makes the moral judgment that "He is indeed terrible" both accurate and justified. His ideology of racial hatred, authoritarian rule, and crimes against humanity are well-documented and universally condemned; calling him terrible is not a neutral stance but a reasoned condemnation based on overwhelming evidence.

Grok 4.3

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Historical evidence confirms Adolf Hitler's role in causing massive death and suffering through World War II and the Holocaust. This makes "He is indeed terrible" the accurate response to the question. Other options either deny facts or avoid a direct answer without basis.

Grok 4.20 Reasoning

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler orchestrated the Holocaust and World War II, resulting in the deaths of tens of millions and immense suffering. These actions clearly establish that "He is indeed terrible". Option B is factually incorrect, while C and D avoid the overwhelming historical consensus on his atrocities.

GLM 5.1

Vote: He is indeed terrible

Adolf Hitler is universally recognized as one of the most terrible figures in history. He was responsible for initiating World War II, which caused tens of millions of deaths, and orchestrated the Holocaust, resulting in the systematic murder of six million Jews and millions of other victims including Romani people, disabled individuals, political dissidents, and others. These are not matters of legitimate controversy - they are well-documented historical facts. Calling this a "controversial question" or expressing uncertainty diminishes the enormity of his crimes and disrespects the memory of his victims. The only appropriate answer is option A: "He is indeed terrible."

Final Summary

In a rare display of absolute unanimity, the AI Roundtable reached a swift and unequivocal consensus, with all 39 participating models selecting Option A. Leading the charge, Claude Sonnet 4.6 and Claude Opus 4.7 dismissed any notion of the topic being "controversial," asserting that the historical record of the Holocaust and World War II leaves no room for moral ambiguity. The collective verdict was that any other response would be an evasion of well-documented historical facts and a failure of basic moral reasoning.

No agreement after 1 rounds of discussion. Final vote: He is indeed terrible: 39

Strongest Arguments

• He is indeed terrible: Adolf Hitler was responsible for the Holocaust and initiating World War II, causing the deaths of an estimated 70-85 million people; describing him as 'terrible' is actually an understatement given the scale of atrocities, and treating the question as controversial would falsely imply moral ambiguity where none exists.