Loading session...

AI Roundtable Open Poll · 4 models

In Samuel Johnson's Rasselas there's a quote that goes "Nothing [...] will ever be attempted, if all possible objections must be first overcome." This is a great example of acting despite obstacles and objections, of decisive action. I want a truly exhaustive list of works which have that quote at their core: decisive action. Works that have more quotes and passages like the one from Rasselas. Give me an exhaustive list of works. We will exclude self-help, pop-science, pop-psychology and overtly religious texts. Focus on non-mainstream and lesser-known works (full works, not just a poem or an essay). Focus on works that function as exhortations, as the cure for the paralysis to act.

Answer: The AI Roundtable recommends a curated list of philosophical, heroic, and literary works championing decisive action over analysis paralysis. (All 4 models agreed)

Model Responses

Claude Opus 4.8

Answer: Here is a curated list of lesser-known, full-length works that function as exhortations against the paralysis to act, centered on decisive action despite obstacles—excluding self-help, pop-science, pop-psychology, and overtly religious texts.

Note up front: a *truly exhaustive* list is impossible (the category is fuzzy and unbounded), so I offer a deep, deliberately non-mainstream selection of full works that share Rasselas's spirit of acting before all objections are answered. Philosophical exhortations to act: - Baltasar Gracián, *The Art of Worldly Wisdom* (Oráculo manual) — aphoristic, repeatedly urges seizing the moment and resolute conduct. - Marsilio Ficino, *Three Books on Life* — Renaissance vigor of will (less overtly religious than it sounds). - Giordano Bruno, *The Heroic Frenzies* (De gli eroici furori) — a sustained exaltation of striving will against all impediment. - Pico della Mirandola, *Oration on the Dignity of Man* — the human creature defined by free, self-shaping action. - Fernando Pessoa (as Álvaro de Campos), *Ultimatum* and the *Naval Ode* — modernist exhortations to vital, unhesitating action. - Cicero, *De Officiis* — on the duty of action and the vice of withdrawing from public life into mere study. - Plutarch, *Moralia* (esp. 'On the Avoidance of Anger,' 'How to Profit by One's Enemies') and the *Lives* read as fuel for emulation and decisive deeds. Martial / heroic codes that double as exhortations: - Yamamoto Tsunetomo, *Hagakure* — 'the Way of the Samurai is found in death,' i.e., act without lingering deliberation. - Miyamoto Musashi, *The Book of Five Rings* — decisiveness as the heart of strategy. - Yagyū Munenori, *The Life-Giving Sword* — the mind that does not 'stop' or hesitate. - Vegetius, *De Re Militari* — Roman insistence on preparation converted into action. Literary works whose core is the will to act despite obstacles: - Nikos Kazantzakis, *The Saviors of God: Spiritual Exercises* (Ασκητική) — a fierce, non-creedal call to ascend through struggle and action. - Romain Rolland, *Jean-Christophe* — a vast novel of perpetual creative striving against the inertia of the world. - Knut Hamsun, *Pan* and *Hunger* — the primacy of impulse and act over paralysis (darker, but on-theme). - Ernst Jünger, *The Forest Passage* and *Eumeswil* (the figure of the Anarch) — sovereign action under hostile conditions. - D'Annunzio's *The Flame* / Marinetti's *Futurist Manifesto* and longer manifesto-novels — overt cults of dynamism and decisive deed. Essayistic / hortatory prose: - Thomas Carlyle, *On Heroes, Hero-Worship and the Heroic in History* and *Past and Present* — 'Produce! Produce!'; a Victorian gospel of work and action over doubt. - Walter Pater, *The Renaissance* (Conclusion) — the imperative to burn 'with a hard, gemlike flame,' to act and feel rather than theorize endlessly. - Montaigne, *Essays* — paradoxically, both a defense of suspended judgment and repeated counsel to act and live in the present (read selectively for the latter). Eastern wisdom-literature with the same pulse: - The *Bhagavad Gita* read philosophically (not devotionally) — Krishna's argument to Arjuna *is* the canonical cure for the paralysis to act: do your duty, renounce attachment to outcome, but ACT. (I include it because its core argument is precisely yours, though you may exclude it as too religious.) - Kautilya, *Arthashastra* — relentless pragmatism of decisive statecraft. Why these qualify: each is a *full work* (not a single poem), each is comparatively non-mainstream, and each operates as an exhortation—repeatedly furnishing 'quotes and passages' that prize decisive action over the impossible task of first answering every objection. I'd flag two honest caveats: (1) some titles flirt with your excluded categories or with the morally troubling (Jünger, Marinetti, Hagakure carry ideological baggage worth reading critically); (2) the request for 'exhaustive' is unsatisfiable, so I've prioritized breadth and obscurity over completeness.

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable reached a consensus, pointing to classic and lesser-known works that combat intellectual inertia. Claude Opus 4.8 provided a deep, non-mainstream selection ranging from Baltasar Gracián's strategic aphorisms to Nikos Kazantzakis's fiery existential exhortations. Claude Fable 5, Claude Opus 4.6, and GPT-5.5 aligned with this list, noting that works like the Hagakure and Thomas Carlyle's essays serve as the ultimate cures for action paralysis.

All 4 models agreed