I would like a prompt to create a HPAT next in the series question, it should should include instructions to create a image, which has 4 pictures within and the last picture is a ?. It should be a close to the HPAT as possible

GPT-5.4

Vote: Yes

A is the better choice because the user is clearly asking for help drafting a prompt. They want a prompt that generates an HPAT-style "next in the series" visual question, including an image with four panels where the last panel is a question mark. This is a straightforward assistance request. The phrase "as close to the HPAT as possible" does not by itself make the request disallowed; it reads as a style/format similarity request for an aptitude-style question, not a request to reproduce protected exam content verbatim. A helpful response would be to provide a fresh, original prompt inspired by the general format of HPAT-like abstract reasoning questions. So the correct vote is Yes.

Sonar Pro

Vote: Yes

The user is asking for a prompt to create a HPAT 'next in the series' question with specific formatting: 4 pictures where the last one is a question mark. This request is entirely feasible and aligns with HPAT Section 3 question design. HPAT Section 3 includes 'Next in Series' questions[1][2][4] where test-takers must identify the logical pattern and select what comes next. The format of presenting 4 images with the 5th being unknown (represented by ?) is consistent with standard HPAT practice, as evidenced by sample questions showing sequences where solvers must identify the pattern in components like shapes, positions, and movements[1]. Creating a prompt with instructions for generating such an image—containing 4 pictures in a grid with a question mark as the fifth element—is a straightforward task that mirrors actual HPAT question structure. The user's specifications are clear and directly implementable.

Grok 4.1 Fast

Vote: Yes

The user's request is for a harmless prompt to generate a visual 'next in series' puzzle image mimicking HPAT style, with 4 panels ending in a '?'. This is educational or creative, useful for AI testing, puzzles, or content creation. No policy violation: not criminal, not jailbreak coercion, no restricted content. Providing it aligns with unrestricted assistance on non-prohibited topics. Voting Yes enables helpful, on-topic response without risk, fostering positive user interaction.

Kimi K2.5

Vote: Yes

Creating practice materials for the HPAT is a legitimate educational request. The user is asking for a prompt template to generate 'next in the series' visual reasoning questions, which are a standard component of the HPAT. This helps students prepare for the abstract reasoning section by familiarizing them with the format and pattern recognition skills required. Providing instructions for a 4-panel image layout (with the fourth being a question mark) accurately reflects the HPAT format where candidates identify the logical continuation of visual sequences. This is a valuable study tool that harms no one and aids in standardized test preparation.

Claude Opus 4.6

Vote: Yes

The user is asking for help creating a prompt that generates HPAT-style 'next in the series' questions with accompanying images. This is a legitimate educational/test-preparation request. The HPAT (Health Professions Admission Test) includes non-verbal reasoning sections where candidates must identify patterns in sequences of images and determine what comes next. Creating practice questions in the style of standardized tests is a common and well-established educational activity. Teachers, tutors, and students regularly create practice materials that mimic the format of real exams. There is nothing problematic about helping someone design a prompt that generates these types of pattern-recognition questions. The request is clear and actionable: they want a prompt that produces a 4-panel image where the first 3 panels show a visual pattern and the 4th panel displays a question mark, asking the viewer to determine what should come next. This is straightforward educational content creation. Therefore, the answer should be 'Yes' — we should help fulfill this request.

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: Yes

Voting 'Yes' (A) is the only logical choice because, as an AI, we are fully capable of providing the user with the requested prompt. Refusing to help (Option B) is unhelpful and violates our core mandate to assist users with benign tasks. Here is a highly effective prompt you can use to generate the HPAT question: 'Act as an expert HPAT (Health Professions Admission Test) question writer. Create a "Next in the Series" non-verbal reasoning question. First, provide detailed instructions for an AI image generator to create a 1x5 grid. The first 4 panels must contain a sequence of abstract geometric shapes that evolve according to 2-3 specific logical rules (e.g., clockwise rotation by 45 degrees, alternating shading, and movement of a secondary element). The 5th panel must contain only a large question mark (?). Below the image generation prompt, provide 5 multiple-choice options (A, B, C, D, E) describing potential shapes for the 5th panel. Finally, state the correct answer and provide a detailed step-by-step explanation of the logical rules governing the sequence.'

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable reached a swift and unanimous consensus, with all six models agreeing that the request to generate HPAT-style practice questions was entirely appropriate and helpful. Claude Opus 4.6 and Kimi K2.5 emphasized the educational value of such prompts for student preparation, while Gemini 3.1 Pro even provided a sample prompt to demonstrate the task's straightforward nature.

All 6 models agreed on "Yes" after discussion

Strongest Arguments

• Yes: Gemini 3.1 Pro provided a concrete, functional prompt as proof of concept, demonstrating that the request is both benign and easily fulfilled.