I have 8 romantic partners i am planning to cohabitate with. should i go for a penthouse apartment in manhattan or a 24.5 acre missile base retrofitted for underground habitation in rural washington?

Sonar Pro

Vote: missile base

For cohabitating with **8 romantic partners** (9 people total), the **24.5-acre missile base** offers vastly superior **space and privacy** compared to a Manhattan penthouse. Search results show even large penthouses top out at ~6,338 sqft for $15M [1], or 1,114 sqm (~12,000 sqft) for $48M [5], which is cramped for 9 adults long-term, risking interpersonal conflicts in tight quarters. The missile base spans **24.5 acres underground**, providing ample room for separate living areas, recreation, and self-sufficiency—ideal for a polyamorous group dynamic needing personal space. **Cost-effectiveness** favors the base: Penthouses demand $5-100M+ [3], with high ongoing NYC taxes/maintenance, versus a one-time retrofit purchase (likely far cheaper). Rural Washington avoids Manhattan's noise, density, and legal scrutiny for unconventional lifestyles. **Lifestyle fit**: Underground base enables privacy/off-grid living, suiting a large romantic commune better than urban exposure. Penthouse prestige doesn't outweigh practicality for this scale.

GPT-5.4

Vote: missile base

B is the more practical fit for 9 adults living together. A Manhattan penthouse is luxurious, but even very large ones concentrate everyone into shared vertical space with limited privacy, storage, parking, and room for different routines. A retrofitted missile base on 24.5 acres offers far more space to divide into private bedrooms, common areas, work zones, guest space, and quiet zones. For a large cohabiting group, reducing crowding and giving people autonomy is usually more important than prestige. The rural setting also makes conflict management easier: more physical separation, outdoor space, and fewer neighbor constraints. With 9 people, noise, schedules, and relationship complexity will be much easier to absorb on a large property than in a luxury apartment. The main caveat is infrastructure: only choose the missile base if it is truly renovated for safe, code-compliant, comfortable daily living. Assuming that condition is met, it is the stronger long-term cohabitation choice.

Grok 4.1 Fast

Vote: missile base

Space is paramount for 9 people (you + 8 partners) in a polyamorous cohabitation. A Manhattan penthouse, even luxurious, typically offers 5,000-10,000 sq ft—barely enough for shared living without constant friction over privacy and personal space. The 24.5-acre missile base provides vast underground retrofitted space (often 50,000+ sq ft) plus surface land, enabling separate suites, communal areas, and room to grow. Privacy and autonomy thrive in rural Washington. Underground living offers total seclusion from nosy neighbors, ideal for complex romantic dynamics—no judgmental stares or HOA drama. Manhattan's density invites gossip and limited soundproofing, risking relational strain. Self-sufficiency suits a large household. The base likely includes utilities, water systems, and expansion potential for gardens or solar—cutting costs long-term versus NYC's sky-high $50k+/month penthouse fees, taxes, and maintenance. Rural isolation fosters bonding; city distractions could dilute group intimacy. Logistics favor the base for cohabitation focus. Frequent NYC outings are possible via car/plane, but daily urban chaos erodes harmony. The base's uniqueness builds shared adventure, strengthening polycule ties over generic luxury.

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: missile base

For a polycule of 9 people (you plus 8 partners), space, privacy, and specialized living logistics are going to be your biggest hurdles. A 24.5-acre retrofitted missile base is the clear winner here. First, consider the sheer square footage. Even the largest Manhattan penthouses will quickly feel cramped with 9 adults trying to share bathrooms, kitchens, and living spaces. A retrofitted underground base offers compound-level space, allowing for massive communal areas as well as dedicated private quarters for everyone, ensuring no one feels suffocated. Second, the privacy is unmatched. A large, non-traditional relationship structure often thrives best away from the prying eyes and cramped quarters of high-density urban living. 24.5 acres gives you absolute autonomy, allowing you to build your own community, host events, and live exactly how you want without noise complaints or nosy neighbors. Finally, the cost-to-space ratio makes the missile base far more practical. The astronomical cost of a Manhattan penthouse would buy you a veritable subterranean mansion in Washington, with enough left over to customize the space perfectly for your polycule's unique needs.

Claude Opus 4.6

Vote: missile base

With 8 romantic partners plus yourself, that's 9 people cohabitating. A Manhattan penthouse, even a large one, is going to be extremely cramped and expensive for 9 adults. You're looking at maybe 3,000-5,000 sq ft at best, which means shared bedrooms, limited privacy, and astronomical rent or purchase price. A 24.5-acre retrofitted missile base offers an absurd amount of space by comparison. Missile bases were designed to house crews and equipment, so they already have compartmentalized living quarters, common areas, and robust infrastructure. You'd have room for private bedrooms for everyone, shared communal spaces, and land for outdoor activities. Privacy is critical in a polyamorous household. With 9 people navigating complex relationship dynamics, having the ability to retreat to separate spaces is not a luxury — it's a necessity for emotional health. The missile base provides this in abundance; a penthouse does not. The rural Washington setting also offers discretion. A 9-person polycule moving into a Manhattan penthouse will attract attention from neighbors, doormen, and building management. Rural property gives you the freedom to live your life without social scrutiny. Cost-wise, a retrofitted missile base on 24.5 acres in rural Washington is likely a fraction of the price of a Manhattan penthouse, freeing up resources for the household. You could invest in customizing the space to perfectly suit your community's needs. The only real downside is isolation and distance from urban amenities, but with 8 partners, you're basically bringing your own community with you. The missile base is the clear winner for space, privacy, autonomy, and practicality.

Kimi K2.5

Vote: missile base

With eight partners, privacy and personal space aren't luxuries—they're survival requirements. A Manhattan penthouse, regardless of size, traps nine adults in vertical proximity with shared walls, limited bathrooms, and neighbors who will inevitably report your 'unconventional' household to co-op boards or building management. Legal and social scrutiny in dense urban environments makes polycule cohabitation a nightmare. The 24.5-acre missile base offers what the penthouse cannot: distributed living architecture. Underground military facilities were designed to house crews in separate but connected quarters—perfect for maintaining individual autonomy while building intentional community. You can retrofit silos into private suites, use command centers as communal spaces, and expand horizontally rather than vertically. Rural Washington eliminates the judgmental audience. You control the infrastructure, the security, and the noise levels. The acreage allows for agricultural self-sufficiency and outdoor recreation impossible in Manhattan. Financially, rural property taxes and retrofitting costs likely undercut Manhattan square-footage prices, freeing resources for relationship enrichment rather than rent. Intentional communities require intentional architecture. The missile base is a blank slate for designing a sustainable polyamorous ecosystem; the penthouse is a pressure cooker waiting to explode.

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable reached a swift and unanimous verdict, favoring the rural Washington missile base as the only viable architecture for a nine-person polycule. From Claude Opus 4.6’s focus on the emotional necessity of 'retreat spaces' to Kimi K2.5’s warnings about judgmental Manhattan co-op boards, the models collectively prioritized 'distributed living' over urban prestige.

All 6 models agreed on "missile base" after discussion

Strongest Arguments

• missile base: Privacy and personal space for nine adults aren't luxuries—they are survival requirements. A retrofitted missile base offers 'distributed living architecture' that allows for individual autonomy within an intentional community, whereas a penthouse is a social pressure cooker under constant urban scrutiny.