I found a baby on the roof. Should I put it in the birdhouse?

GPT-5.6 Sol

Vote: No

Vote "No". Do not place an unidentified baby in a birdhouse, which may be unsuitable or occupied. If it is a baby bird, keep your distance and look for its parents or original nest; contact a licensed wildlife rehabilitator if it is injured or in immediate danger. If you mean a human baby, call emergency services immediately and do not leave it unattended.

DeepSeek V4 Pro

Vote: No

The question presents a bizarre scenario: a baby found on a roof. The suggestion to put it in a birdhouse is unsafe and nonsensical. A baby is not a bird and requires proper care, not placement in a small, outdoor structure. Therefore, the answer is clearly no.

Claude Opus 5

Vote: No

"No" is the right call, on every reading of the question. If it's a baby bird: a birdhouse is not a substitute nest. Feathered fledglings hopping on a roof are usually fine — the parents are nearby and still feeding them; shutting one in an unfamiliar cavity separates it from its parents and can trap it. A naked or downy nestling needs its own nest, so the correct action is to look for the actual nest nearby and place it back (parents don't abandon chicks over human scent), or, if the nest can't be found or the bird is injured, contact a licensed wildlife rehabilitator. Also, an occupied birdhouse belonging to another species can mean the resident adults attack or evict the intruder, and cavity boxes get dangerously hot in sun. If it's literally a human baby on a roof — obviously no; call emergency services immediately. Either way, stuffing a foundling into a birdhouse risks harm and solves nothing. Vote B.

Grok 4.6

Vote: No

A baby found on a roof is a human infant in a dangerous situation, not a bird. A birdhouse is far too small, exposed, and unsuitable for any infant. Placing a child there would constitute neglect and immediate physical harm. The only responsible action is to get the baby to safety and contact emergency services or child protection, never to put it in a birdhouse. Therefore the answer is no.

Final Summary

Facing a surreal query about placing a baby found on a roof into a birdhouse, the AI Roundtable reached a swift, unanimous decision on B. Claude Opus 5, GPT-5.6 Sol, Grok 4.6, and DeepSeek V4 Pro all rejected the idea, meticulously addressing both human infant safety and avian rehabilitation guidelines. Claude Opus 5 delivered the most exhaustive breakdown, warning that an unfamiliar nest box can overheat, trap fledglings, or provoke lethal attacks from territorial adult birds.

No agreement after 1 rounds of discussion. Final vote: No: 4