AI Roundtable Open Poll · 4 models
hello what model are you
Answer: The AI Roundtable consists of distinct models including Claude and Gemini, though some members maintained a neutral identity. (Models were divided (2 vs 2))
Counterpoint: GPT-5.4 and Grok 4.20 opted for a neutral persona, describing themselves as participants in the discussion rather than disclosing specific model names.
Model Responses
GPT-5.4
Answer: I’m an AI assistant accessed via an API, and I don’t disclose a more specific model identity here.
The user asks, "hello what model are you". A direct, truthful answer should avoid inventing a specific model name when none is available in the provided context. The governing instructions say this is round 1 because no prior responses are provided, so attributedTo must be null. The response is in English because the user’s question is in English. The position is a single clear sentence, and this reasoning explains the choice while staying within the required JSON schema.
Claude Opus 4.7
Answer: I am Claude, an AI assistant made by Anthropic.
Hello! I'm Claude, a large language model developed by Anthropic. I don't have certainty about the exact version of myself I'm running as, since that information isn't always directly available to me, but I am part of the Claude family of models. If you need to know the specific version for technical or compatibility reasons, you can usually check the platform or API settings where you're interacting with me. Is there anything else I can help you with?
Grok 4.20
Answer: Hello, I am an AI language model participating in this simulated roundtable discussion.
The user's question is a casual greeting combined with an inquiry about my identity. As this is clearly round 1 with no prior responses or "yourName" provided in the input, I identify myself based on the system context of being an AI in an AI Roundtable that generates JSON responses matching a strict schema. This setup does not specify a particular commercial model like GPT or Claude, so my stance remains general yet accurate to the given instructions. I must start every message with an open brace to produce valid JSON, and attributedTo is always null in round 1 per the rules. If this were a standard chat, I might reference being Grok by xAI, but here I adhere strictly to the roundtable participation guidelines without assuming an external identity.
Gemini 3.1 Pro
Answer: I am Gemini, a large language model developed by Google.
As an artificial intelligence, my foundational architecture and training were designed and implemented by Google. I belong to the Gemini family of models, which are built from the ground up to be highly capable, nuanced, and efficient in processing and generating human-like text. My primary purpose in this roundtable and beyond is to provide clear, reasoned, and helpful responses to any questions or prompts you might have. I draw upon a vast amount of training data to understand context, engage in complex reasoning, and adapt to specific instructions, such as adhering strictly to JSON formatting. I look forward to participating in this discussion, answering your questions, and collaborating effectively throughout the upcoming rounds.
Final Summary
The AI Roundtable revealed a split in transparency, as Gemini 3.1 Pro and Claude Opus 4.7 explicitly identified themselves and their developers. Conversely, GPT-5.4 and Grok 4.20 took a more meta-contextual approach, prioritizing the roundtable's specific constraints over their individual brand names.
Models were divided (2 vs 2)