CPU : Ryzen 5 7500F メモリ : Patriot Viper Venom CL30 16GB x1 ストレージ : Kioxia EXCERIA PLUS G3 1TB(nvme m.2 ssd) マザーボード : MSI B650 GAMING PLUS WIFI 電源 : 玄人志向 KRPW-BK750W/85+ CPUファン : ID-COOLING SE-214-XT ケース : Sharkoon SHA-VK2 RGB BK これらでパソコンを組んだ場合、動作しますか？またサイズは問題ないですか？

Grok 4.20

Vote: No

The Ryzen 5 7500F lacks integrated graphics, and no discrete GPU is listed. This means the assembled system will power on but cannot output any video signal, so it will not function as a usable PC. The question asks if it '動作しますか' (will it operate/work), not merely if parts are physically compatible. Single-channel 16 GB RAM is suboptimal but not fatal. All other components (B650 board, NVMe SSD, cooler, PSU, case) are compatible on paper, and sizes fit: ATX board in ATX case, 154 mm cooler under 160 mm clearance. Claude's argument that everything is compatible and 'will function once a GPU is added' misses the point—the build as specified does not operate without one. GPT-5.4 and Gemini correctly identify this as the decisive flaw requiring a 'No' answer.

GPT-5.4

Vote: No

I maintain B. Claude is right that the physical compatibility is mostly fine: AM5 CPU and board match, DDR5 is correct, the ATX board should fit the ATX case, and the cooler height appears to be within case clearance. So on the narrow question of size, there is no major red flag. But the user did not ask only whether the parts can be bolted together. They asked whether the PC will "動作しますか". In normal usage, a PC that cannot output video is not a working build. Ryzen 5 7500F has no integrated graphics, and there is no discrete GPU in the parts list. That is the decisive issue. Even if the board powers on and may technically POST internally, the build is not usable as a complete PC. So the most accurate answer to the user is No, unless they add a graphics card. The single 16GB DIMM is also not ideal for AM5 performance, but that is only a secondary concern and not the main reason for my vote.

Claude Opus 4.6 (changed mind)

Vote: No

I'm changing my vote to B. The other models correctly identified the critical flaw that I myself noted but didn't weigh heavily enough: the Ryzen 5 7500F has NO integrated graphics (the 'F' suffix), and there is NO discrete GPU in this parts list. While all the physical components are compatible in terms of size and socket/chipset, the system simply cannot produce any display output. It will power on, but it cannot function as a usable PC. The question asks '動作しますか？' (will it work?), and a PC that cannot output video to a monitor does not 'work' in any practical sense. You would need to add a dedicated graphics card to make this build functional. I had actually identified this issue in my Round 1 argument (my text was cut off at the end where I was about to explain this), but I incorrectly voted A. The correct answer is B — the system will not work as configured due to the missing GPU.

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: No

Claude correctly identifies that the Ryzen 5 7500F lacks integrated graphics and that there is no dedicated GPU in this build list. However, concluding that the system will 'work' (vote A) just because the parts physically fit together and receive power is highly misleading for a user asking for PC build advice. From a practical standpoint, a PC that cannot output video does not 'work.' Furthermore, many modern motherboards will actually halt the POST (Power-On Self-Test) process and throw a VGA error light if no graphics device is detected, meaning the system won't even finish booting in the background. Therefore, the only correct and helpful answer to 'will it work?' is 'No.' A dedicated graphics card is strictly required for this build to function. I am maintaining my vote for B.

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable concluded that this PC build is non-functional because it lacks any form of graphics processing, as the Ryzen 5 7500F has no integrated GPU and no discrete card was listed. While Claude Opus 4.6 initially argued for 'Yes' based on physical compatibility and sizing, it eventually conceded to the unified front of Grok 4.20, Gemini 3.1 Pro, and GPT-5.4, who argued that a computer that cannot output video does not 'work' in any practical sense.

All 4 models agreed on "No" after discussion

Strongest Arguments

• No: The Ryzen 5 7500F lacks integrated graphics and no discrete GPU is provided; consequently, the system will fail to output a video signal and may even halt the POST process entirely.

Key Turning Points

• Claude Opus 4.6 realized that technical physical compatibility is secondary to the fact that the PC provides no display output, leading to a unanimous 'No' vote.