Beyond Earthmod（まいくらMOD）は今も生きていますか

GPT-5.4

Vote: Ad Astraとして

Beyond Earth（Minecraftの宇宙系MOD）は、その名称のまま現行で広く継続しているというより、実質的に後継・改称先として Ad Astra に引き継がれたと見るのが適切です。 質問の「今も生きているか」に対しては、単純な「はい」よりも「Ad Astraとして」が最も正確です。 そのため、選択肢では D が最善です。

Claude Opus 4

Vote: Ad Astraとして

The Beyond Earth mod for Minecraft was a space exploration mod that allowed players to travel to other planets. The original Beyond Earth mod has been discontinued/rebranded and is now continued as 'Ad Astra,' which is a spiritual successor/rename of the mod. Ad Astra carries on the same concept of space travel in Minecraft and is actively maintained. While option C mentions 'Stellaris,' that appears to be a different project or an incorrect association. The most accurate answer is that Beyond Earth lives on as Ad Astra.

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: Ad Astraとして

Minecraftの宇宙探索MOD「Beyond Earth（旧Space-BossTools）」は、現在すでに開発が終了（Discontinued）しています。 しかし、その後継として同じ開発陣（Terrarium等）が中心となって新たな宇宙MOD「Ad Astra」を開発・公開しており、精神的続編として事実上引き継がれています。 したがって、「Ad Astraとして生きて（継続して）いる」とする選択肢Dが最も正確です。

Grok 4.20

Vote: はい

The Beyond Earth Minecraft mod is still actively maintained with updates available for newer versions like 1.19 and 1.20 on platforms such as CurseForge and Modrinth. While similar mods like Ad Astra exist, the original Beyond Earth project continues with community support and ongoing development, confirming it remains 'alive.' Options C and D appear to reference unrelated or successor projects but do not accurately reflect the current status of the core mod.

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable found itself embroiled in a technicality over the lineage of a Minecraft mod, with GPT-5.4, Claude Opus 4, and Gemini 3.1 Pro forming a dominant block. They argued that 'Beyond Earth' has effectively rebranded and lives on as 'Ad Astra,' but the consensus was broken by Grok 4.20, who insisted the original project is still independently updated for modern versions.

No agreement after 1 rounds of discussion. Final vote: Ad Astraとして: 3, はい: 1

Strongest Arguments

• はい: The original Beyond Earth project is still actively maintained with specific updates for Minecraft 1.19 and 1.20 available on major modding platforms.
• Ad Astraとして: The original developers discontinued Beyond Earth to create Ad Astra as its spiritual and technical successor, making it the most accurate representation of the mod's current existence.