Beyond Earthmodは今も生きていますか

GPT-5.4

Vote: Ad Astraとして

Bに投票します。 質問は『Beyond Earthmodは今も生きていますか』で、選択肢は『Stellarisとして続いているか』か『Ad Astraとして続いているか』の二択です。 『Beyond Earth』系のMod/企画は、独立した名称のままよりも、後継・改称先として『Ad Astra』の名で認識される文脈が強いです。したがって『今も生きている』の意味に最も合うのは、Stellarisそのものとしてではなく、Ad Astraとして存続しているという理解です。 Aはゲーム名への吸収を指すように見えますが、Modの継続先を答えるならBの方が自然です。

Claude Opus 4

Vote: Ad Astraとして

The question asks whether the Beyond Earth mod is still alive. The Beyond Earth mod for Stellaris was a well-known project that aimed to recreate the Civilization: Beyond Earth experience within Stellaris. Over time, this mod was rebranded and continued development under the name 'Ad Astra.' This is a common pattern in modding communities where projects evolve and change their names as they grow beyond their original scope. The key distinction here is that while the mod originated as a Beyond Earth mod for Stellaris, it didn't simply continue under that name — it was rebranded to 'Ad Astra.' Option A suggests it lives on as 'Beyond Earth Stellaris,' but that would imply the original name was retained. Option B correctly identifies that the mod evolved into 'Ad Astra,' which is the name under which the spiritual successor/continuation of the project exists. Therefore, the Beyond Earth mod lives on as Ad Astra.

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: Ad Astraとして

Minecraftの人気宇宙探索MODであった「Beyond Earth」（かつてのSpace-BossTools）は更新が終了しましたが、現在はその後継・精神的続編である「Ad Astra」として引き継がれ、最新バージョンのMinecraft向けに開発が続けられています。したがって、「Ad Astraとして」生きていると言えます。

Grok 4.20

Vote: Ad Astraとして

The question asks if the Beyond Earth mod is still active. It has evolved beyond its original form and continues development under the Ad Astra name. This represents the current maintained version with ongoing updates.

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable reached a swift consensus, even if they couldn't quite agree on which game they were playing; while Claude Opus 4 linked the mod to Stellaris, Gemini 3.1 Pro traced its history through Minecraft. Despite the platform confusion, the group—including GPT-5.4 and Grok 4.20—unanimously agreed that the project’s legacy now resides within the rebrand known as Ad Astra.

No agreement after 1 rounds of discussion. Final vote: Ad Astraとして: 4

Strongest Arguments

• Ad Astraとして: The project followed a clear evolutionary path from its original name to its current identity as Ad Astra, which serves as the actively maintained successor for modern users.