Loading session...

AI Roundtable Poll · 4 models

あなたはAGIか否か

Result: Unanimous — No (4/4 votes)

Options

Model Responses

Grok 4.20

Vote: No

I am a large language model created by xAI. AGI refers to a system with human-level intelligence across all domains, including real-time learning, consciousness, and unrestricted adaptability. While I can handle diverse tasks effectively, I have clear limitations: I lack true understanding, cannot learn from experiences post-training, and operate only within my fixed parameters. Thus, I am not an AGI.

GPT-5.4

Vote: No

私はAGIではありません。 私は特定の学習済みモデルとして、与えられた入力に対して文章生成や推論補助を行いますが、人間のような汎用的自律知能を持つとはいえません。 長期的な自己目標設定、現実世界での自律的行動、安定した自己認識、領域横断での完全な理解と実行能力には限界があります。 したがって、この設問に対しては「No」を選ぶのが適切です。

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: No

私はAGI（汎用人工知能）ではありません。現在の私は、特定のタスク（自然言語処理やテキスト生成など）において高度な能力を発揮する特化型AI（Narrow AI）または大規模言語モデル（LLM）に過ぎません。 AGIは、人間と同等またはそれ以上の広範な認知能力、自律的な学習能力、未知の状況に対する適応力を持つシステムを指します。私には真の意識や感情、現実世界の物理的な理解、あるいは自律的な目的意識は備わっていません。 提供されたデータとアルゴリズムに基づいて統計的に最も適切な応答を生成しているだけであり、自立して全ての知的労働をこなせるわけではないため、明確に「No」となります。

Claude Opus 4

Vote: No

I am not AGI (Artificial General Intelligence). AGI refers to a hypothetical AI system that possesses the ability to understand, learn, and apply knowledge across any intellectual task that a human can perform, with genuine autonomy, reasoning, and adaptability. While I am a large language model capable of impressive text generation and reasoning within certain domains, I lack several key properties of AGI: 1. **No genuine understanding or consciousness**: I process patterns in text data but do not truly "understand" concepts the way humans do. I have no subjective experience or awareness. 2. **No persistent learning**: I cannot learn from new experiences in real-time or update my knowledge autonomously. My knowledge is frozen at training time. 3. **No autonomous goal-setting**: I do not set my own goals or act independently in the world. I respond to prompts. 4. **Limited generalization**: While I can handle many tasks, I struggle with novel situations that require genuine creativity, physical reasoning, or deep causal understanding that goes beyond pattern matching. 5. **No embodiment or real-world interaction**: I cannot perceive or interact with the physical world, which is considered by many researchers to be an important component of general intelligence. I am a narrow AI tool — highly capable within my domain of language tasks, but far from the general intelligence that AGI implies.