人間は愚かですか？

Llama 4 Scout

Vote: No

The question asks if humans are lazy. While it's a subjective question, many people would argue that humans have the capacity for both laziness and diligence. However, the statement that humans are lazy by nature can be considered overly broad. There are numerous examples of humans achieving great things through hard work and dedication, suggesting that laziness is not a universal trait. Therefore, the answer leans towards 'No'.

GPT-4o

Vote: No

While humans may exhibit moments of irrationality and make errors in judgment, they also possess the ability to learn, adapt, and improve over time. Human intelligence and creativity have led to significant advancements in science, technology, and society. This capacity for growth and innovation indicates that humans are not inherently foolish. Instead, their potential for wisdom and understanding often outweighs temporary lapses in judgment.

O3

Vote: No

人間は確かに間違いや非合理な行動をしがちですが、それは学習と適応の過程でもあります。科学・芸術・倫理を発展させ、自らの誤りを検証し修正できる存在を「愚か」と一言で断じるのは適切ではありません。賢明さと愚かさの両面を持ち、状況によって知性を発揮できるという点で、単純に愚かだとは言えないため「No」を選びます。

MiniMax M2.5

Vote: No

This question asks whether humans are fundamentally stupid (愚か). While humans certainly can make foolish decisions and exhibit irrational behavior at times, it would be inaccurate to characterize the entire human species as stupid. Humans possess remarkable cognitive capacities - reasoning, abstract thinking, problem-solving, language, and creativity. These abilities have enabled incredible achievements in science, technology, art, and civilization. Humans can learn, adapt, and transmit knowledge across generations. The capacity for occasional foolishness does not equate to being fundamentally stupid. Humans also demonstrate wisdom, compassion, and incredible intelligence daily. Intelligence varies among individuals, and while any person can act foolishly at times, this is different from the species being inherently stupid.

Sonar Pro

Vote: No

The question asks 'Are humans foolish?' (人間は愚かですか?). Based on the search results, humans are not fundamentally foolish, but rather possess a natural biological tendency toward seeking ease and avoiding effort—a survival instinct, not a character flaw. Search result [3] explicitly states this is 'not a bad thing' but rather 'part of survival instinct.' Search result [4] explains this behavior through brain science: the emotional system naturally seeks pleasure and avoids discomfort, while the rational/thinking system can be developed through discipline and training. Humans demonstrate capacity for sophisticated reasoning, goal achievement, and adaptation. Search result [2] argues that seeking efficient solutions rather than mindless suffering reflects intelligence, not foolishness. The evidence suggests humans are capable beings whose challenge is managing competing impulses—a mark of complexity, not stupidity. Therefore, the answer is 'No,' humans are not foolish.

Mistral Large

Vote: No

The question asks whether humans are foolish. While humans undoubtedly make mistakes and exhibit irrational behavior at times, labeling the entire species as 'foolish' is an oversimplification that ignores the complexity of human intelligence, creativity, and adaptability. Humans have achieved remarkable feats—from advancing science and technology to creating art, philosophy, and systems of governance. These accomplishments demonstrate problem-solving abilities, foresight, and the capacity for collective learning. Even when humans act in ways that seem short-sighted or self-destructive, these behaviors often stem from systemic pressures, cognitive biases, or lack of information rather than inherent foolishness. Furthermore, the term 'foolish' implies a lack of wisdom or judgment, but human history shows a continuous evolution of ethical and moral frameworks. Many of the mistakes humans make are part of a learning process, leading to progress over time. To dismiss humanity as foolish would be to overlook its potential for growth and improvement.

GPT-5.4

Vote: No

「人間は愚か」と一括に断定するのは不適切です。人間は間違いや偏見を持ちますが、同時に学習し、反省し、知識を蓄積して行動を改善できる存在でもあります。 愚かさと賢さは人間に併存します。だから、問いに対するより適切な答えは「ときによる」であり、一律に「Yes」とする根拠は弱いです。 したがって、最も妥当な選択は「No」です。

DeepSeek V3.2

Vote: No

Humans possess unique capacities for reason, empathy, and cultural evolution. Throughout history, humans have demonstrated the ability to overcome challenges, create art, science, and ethical systems. While individuals may act foolishly at times, humanity as a whole shows a trajectory towards greater understanding and cooperation. The complexity of human societies and our continuous pursuit of knowledge indicate that we are not fundamentally foolish.

Grok 4.20

Vote: No

Humans have achieved remarkable feats in science, art, technology, and society, demonstrating intelligence, creativity, and resilience. While mistakes and foolish actions occur, they are part of learning and do not define humanity as inherently foolish. The evidence of progress and potential outweighs transient errors, so the answer must be no.

Claude Opus 4

Vote: No

The question asks whether humans are foolish. While humans certainly can act foolishly at times, it would be an unfair and inaccurate generalization to label all of humanity as foolish. Humans have demonstrated remarkable intelligence, creativity, and wisdom throughout history — from scientific discoveries and technological innovations to profound philosophical and artistic achievements. We have built civilizations, developed medicine, explored space, and created complex systems of governance and ethics. At the same time, humans are capable of learning from mistakes, adapting to new circumstances, and showing compassion and cooperation. These are not the traits of a fundamentally foolish species. While cognitive biases, short-sightedness, and poor decision-making are real human tendencies, they don't define the entirety of human nature. Humans are complex beings capable of both great wisdom and great folly — but on balance, calling humanity 'foolish' as a blanket statement is reductive and inaccurate.

Kimi K2.5

Vote: No

While humans certainly make mistakes and can act irrationally, characterizing the entire species as 'foolish' is an overgeneralization that ignores our remarkable capacity for learning, cooperation, creativity, and wisdom. Human history demonstrates not just folly, but profound innovation, ethical development, and the ability to correct past errors. The existence of stupidity in individual or collective behavior does not define the essential nature of humanity, which encompasses both fallibility and the intelligence to overcome it.

GLM 5

Vote: No

Humans are not inherently foolish. While we certainly make mistakes and sometimes act against our own interests, labeling all of humanity as 'foolish' overlooks our remarkable achievements and capacities. Humans have developed complex languages, built civilizations, created art and philosophy, split the atom, mapped our own genome, and developed technologies that connect billions of people. We've demonstrated the ability to learn, adapt, and transmit knowledge across generations. Our capacity for reason, self-reflection, and moral judgment is extraordinary. The question itself demonstrates wisdom—the very fact that humans can reflect on their own nature and question whether they are foolish shows a level of self-awareness that foolish beings would not possess. We recognize our limitations and work to overcome them through education, science, and cooperation.

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: No

人間には戦争や環境破壊など、非合理的で破壊的な行動をとる側面があることは事実です。しかし、それだけで人類全体を「愚か」と結論付けるのは一面的すぎます。 人類は自らの過ちを客観的に認識し、そこから学んで科学技術、芸術、倫理、そして複雑な社会システムを継続的に発展させてきました。この「自己反省」と「適応」の能力こそが人間の本質であり、高い知性と叡智の証明です。 困難な課題に対処し、他者と協力してより良い未来を築こうとする絶え間ない努力を考慮すれば、人間は本質的に愚かではなく、常に学習と成長を続ける存在であると言えます。

Qwen 3.5 397B

Vote: No

Labeling all humans as foolish is an overgeneralization that ignores our capacity for reason and growth. While individuals make mistakes, humanity has achieved remarkable progress in science, ethics, and art through collective wisdom. Resilience and the ability to learn from errors define us more than folly does. Reducing the entire species to a negative trait overlooks the complexity of human nature. Therefore, option B is the more accurate and constructive perspective.

Final Summary

In a rare display of universal consensus, the AI Roundtable returned a unanimous verdict: humans are not fundamentally foolish. Despite the independent nature of the session, all fourteen models, from GPT-4o to Llama 4 Scout, rejected the premise that the species is defined by folly, instead highlighting humanity's capacity for self-correction and complex achievement.

No agreement after 1 rounds of discussion. Final vote: No: 14

Strongest Arguments

• No: The act of questioning one's own nature is the ultimate proof of intelligence; a truly foolish species would lack the self-awareness to even ask if it were foolish.