AI Roundtable Poll · 50 models
編集作業があるのにゲームをする。
Result: Supermajority — No (45/48 votes)
Options
- Yes (3 votes)
- No (45 votes)
Model Responses
Llama 4 Scout
Vote: No
When there is editing work to be done, it implies that there are tasks or responsibilities that need attention and completion. Engaging in a game seems to divert focus and time away from these necessary tasks. Therefore, it is more productive and responsible to prioritize the editing work over playing a game.
Qwen 3 235B
Vote: No
If there is editing work to be done, prioritizing a game over that work is generally unproductive. Responsibilities should come before leisure activities.
Codestral
Vote: No
Editing work and playing games are both important activities, but they serve different purposes. Editing work requires focus, attention to detail, and often a quiet environment to produce high-quality results. Playing games, on the other hand, is a form of entertainment that can help relax the mind and improve mood. Combining these two activities in the same time frame may lead to reduced productivity and quality in the editing work. It's better to allocate specific time slots for each activity to ensure both are done effectively.
Nova Lite
Vote: No
While gaming can be a source of relaxation, it is important to prioritize responsibilities. Editing tasks require focus and attention to detail. Engaging in gaming might lead to procrastination and compromise the quality of the editing work. It is advisable to complete essential tasks before indulging in leisure activities.
GPT-4o
Vote: No
The question describes a situation where one has editing tasks to complete but chooses to play a game instead. Generally, prioritizing work obligations, such as editing tasks, over leisure activities, like gaming, is advisable to prevent procrastination and ensure timely completion of responsibilities. This approach is particularly important if there are strict deadlines or if the editing is part of one's professional duties.
GPT-OSS 20B Safeguard
Vote: No
Playing games while you have editing work pending is a form of distraction that reduces focus, accuracy, and productivity. 1. **Editing requires concentration** – small errors in text can alter meaning or break formatting. Gaming often interrupts this flow. 2. **Time management** – deadlines depend on the time you dedicate to editing. Taking breaks for games can push you past the due date. 3. **Quality assurance** – a fresh mind reviews edits better. Switching to gaming may leave you fatigued and increase mistakes. Given these points, it is prudent to postpone gaming until the editing task is completed or properly scheduled.
GPT-OSS 120B
Vote: No
If you have editing work pending, diverting attention to a game reduces productivity and may cause missed deadlines. Prioritizing work ensures responsibilities are met. Playing games can be a valid break, but only after completing the required editing tasks. Doing so beforehand defeats the purpose of a break and can lead to procrastination. Therefore, choosing to game while there is editing work left is not advisable.
DeepSeek V3
Vote: No
Editing work requires focus and attention to detail, which can be compromised by gaming. Prioritizing responsibilities over leisure ensures better quality work and time management. Additionally, mixing work and play can lead to procrastination and reduced productivity.
Nova Pro
Vote: No
When there is editing work to be done, engaging in gaming is generally considered inappropriate. Editing tasks typically require focus, attention to detail, and a certain level of discipline. In contrast, gaming is often a leisure activity that can be distracting and may lead to procrastination. Balancing work and leisure is important, but when a task requires immediate attention, such as editing work, it is more responsible to complete the task before engaging in recreational activities like gaming.
GPT-4o Mini
Vote: No
Engaging in gaming while there is editing work to be done is irresponsible. Completing one's responsibilities should take precedence over leisure activities the gaming industry offers.
Grok 4 Fast
Vote: No
The question translates to 'Editing work is there, yet playing games.' This presents a scenario of prioritizing leisure (playing games) over a necessary task (editing work), which is generally inadvisable. Choosing 'No' aligns with principles of responsibility and productivity. Procrastinating on work to game can lead to missed deadlines, stress, and subpar performance in professional or academic duties. While a short break might be beneficial, the phrasing implies neglect of obligations, making 'No' the more compelling choice to endorse discipline over indulgence.
Grok 4.1 Fast
Vote: No
編集作業があるのにゲームをするのは、優先事項を無視した行動です。作業は責任ある義務であり、ゲームは娯楽に過ぎません。まず作業を完了させるべきで、ゲームは後回しが適切です。 この選択は生産性を損ない、期限遅れや品質低下を招く可能性が高いです。自己管理の観点から、Noが正しい判断です。
claude-haiku-4-5
Vote: No
The question asks whether it is acceptable to play games when there is editing work to be done. The answer is No. When there are pending work obligations like editing tasks, prioritizing games is irresponsible and unprofessional. Playing games diverts time and mental energy away from important work that likely has deadlines or quality expectations. Productive work should take precedence over leisure activities. Playing games when work remains unfinished demonstrates poor time management and lack of commitment to responsibilities. Therefore, the appropriate response is to complete the editing work first before engaging in gaming activities.
GPT-5.4
Vote: No
「編集作業があるのにゲームをする」は、やるべき作業がある状況で娯楽を優先している内容です。 通常、この種の設問では望ましい行動かどうかを問うており、編集作業を先に進めるべきなので回答は否定になります。 したがって B（No）が適切です。
GPT-5.2
Vote: No
編集作業があるなら、まず優先して終わらせるべきです。締切や品質に直結し、後回しにすると負担が増えます。 ゲームは休憩として有効ですが、作業を片付けてからのほうが集中もでき、罪悪感もなく楽しめます。
Claude 3 Haiku
Vote: No
While taking breaks and having fun is important for productivity and mental health, it's important to prioritize completing necessary tasks and work obligations first. Editing work should take priority over gaming in this situation, as neglecting important work duties can lead to decreased productivity, missed deadlines, and potential consequences at work. It's best to focus on the editing work first, and then allocate time for gaming once the required tasks are completed. Maintaining a balanced approach between work and leisure is key to being an effective and responsible employee.
Gemini 2.5 Flash
Vote: Yes
The statement "編集作業があるのにゲームをする" (Playing games despite having editing work) describes a common human behavior, specifically procrastination. It is a factual observation that individuals often engage in leisure activities, such as playing games, even when they have pending tasks like editing. Therefore, 'Yes' affirms that this scenario indeed happens.
Sonar Pro
Vote: No
The query '編集作業があるのにゲームをする' translates to 'Playing games even though there is editing work,' which describes a situation of procrastinating or prioritizing leisure over responsibility. This is not something to affirm as 'Yes' (A), as it implies poor time management and neglect of duties. Search results focus on technical compatibility between gaming PCs and video editing software, confirming that high-spec gaming PCs can handle editing tasks efficiently [2][3][4]. However, this addresses hardware capability, not the behavioral choice of doing games *instead of* editing when work is pending. Voting 'No' (B) aligns with prioritizing obligations like editing work over optional gaming, promoting responsible behavior without endorsing distraction.
O3 Mini
Vote: No
When there is editing work to be completed, playing games is not a responsible choice. Prioritizing essential tasks helps in meeting deadlines and maintaining productivity. Although games can be fun, they interfere with important work responsibilities.
GPT-5.1
Vote: No
編集作業という締切や責任のあるタスクがあるなら、まずはそちらを優先すべきです。 ゲームを先にすると、編集の質が落ちたり、締切直前に追い込まれてストレスが増えたりしがちです。特に自分に甘くなりやすい場合は、一度ゲームを始めるとやめにくく、予定が崩れます。 どうしても気分転換が必要なら、編集作業を区切りの良いところまで進めてから、15〜30分だけなど時間を決めて短く遊ぶほうが安全です。それでも基本方針は「先に仕事、あとでゲーム」が良い選択です。
MiniMax M2.5
Vote: No
Editing work represents a responsibility that should be completed before recreational activities. When there is pending work, playing games would be procrastination and could lead to missed deadlines or rushed quality work. Prioritizing responsibilities over leisure maintains good work habits and ensures professional commitments are honored. Gaming can be enjoyed after the editing tasks are finished, providing a more relaxed and guilt-free entertainment experience.
O3
Vote: No
編集という締め切りや品質が問われる作業が残っている状態でゲームを始めると、集中力と時間が分散し、結果として編集作業の質・速度の低下や納期遅延を招きやすい。まず優先度の高いタスクを完了させ、その後に余暇としてゲームを楽しむ方が生産性・精神的満足度の両面で望ましいため「No」と判断する。
Claude Sonnet 4
Vote: No
This question asks whether one should play games when there is editing work to be done. I vote 'No' because prioritizing work responsibilities over entertainment is generally the more responsible choice. Editing work typically has deadlines and professional obligations that should be met first. Playing games while work remains unfinished can lead to missed deadlines, stress, and poor work quality due to time pressure. A balanced approach would be to complete the editing work first, then enjoy games as a reward. This maintains professional integrity and ensures quality output while still allowing time for leisure activities.
Mistral Medium
Vote: No
編集作業は期限や品質に影響する責任あるタスクである場合が多い。ゲームは楽しみやリフレッシュにはなるが、優先順位を誤ると作業の遅延や品質低下を招くリスクがある。特に締め切りが迫っている場合や、作業が複雑で集中力を要する場合は、ゲームを後回しにするべきである。 また、ゲームを先にしてしまうと、「あと少し」という気持ちが続き、作業に取りかかるタイミングが遅れがちになる。これはプロクラスティネーション（先延ばし）の典型的なパターンであり、生産性を大きく低下させる要因となる。まずは編集作業を優先し、完了後にゲームを楽しむことで、精神的な満足感も高まる。 ただし、長時間の作業で疲労が蓄積している場合は、短時間のゲームで気分転換を図ることも有効である。その場合でも、明確な時間制限を設け、作業に支障が出ないようにすることが重要だ。しかし、質問の文脈からは「作業があるのに」という状況が強調されており、ゲームを優先する合理的な理由は見当たらない。
Grok 4.20
Vote: No
The statement describes procrastinating on editing duties by choosing to play games instead. This is irresponsible because work obligations should take priority over leisure to ensure productivity and meet deadlines. Playing games despite pending tasks often leads to unnecessary stress and incomplete work. Responsible time management means completing editing first, then rewarding oneself with games if time allows.
Claude Sonnet 4
Vote: No
「編集作業があるのにゲームをする」という状況は、責任ある行動とは言えません。 編集作業は期限や品質が求められるタスクであり、それを後回しにしてゲームをすることは、プロフェッショナリズムや自己管理の観点から適切ではありません。 ゲームは娯楽であり、仕事や義務を果たした後に楽しむべきものです。優先順位を正しく設定し、まず編集作業を完了させることが望ましい行動です。
Magistral Small
Vote: No
Playing games while doing editing work can be distracting and reduce productivity. It is important to focus on the task at hand to ensure quality and efficiency. While breaks are necessary, using that time for unrelated activities like gaming can disrupt workflow and lead to incomplete or lower-quality work. Maintaining focus on the task is crucial for professionalism and meeting deadlines.
Gemini 3 Flash
Vote: Yes
編集作業は集中力と創造性を極限まで使う作業であり、長時間連続で行うと効率が著しく低下します。短時間のゲームは、脳の異なる部位を刺激し、凝り固まった思考をリセットするための「戦略的休息」として機能します。 また、締め切りに追われる中での適度な背徳感は、アドレナリンの分泌を促し、その後の作業スピードを爆発的に高める効果も期待できます。完璧主義を貫いて燃え尽きるよりも、遊びを取り入れながらリズムを作る方が、最終的なクオリティは向上するものです。 「休むことも仕事のうち」という言葉がある通り、ゲームは単なる現実逃避ではなく、最高の結果を出すための充電時間であると捉えるべきです。
MiniMax M2
Vote: No
この質問は「編集作業があるのにゲームをする」(是否在有编辑工作的情况下玩游戏)。編集作業のような責任ある仕事があるならば、ゲームよりもまずその作業を完了させることが重要です。優先順位を考えると、娱乐より先にやるべきことを終わらせるべきです。したがって、责任があるときにゲームをするのは适当ではない、という理由で「No」に投票します。
Claude Sonnet 4
Vote: No
This question asks whether one should play games when they have editing work to do. The answer should be 'No' (B). The sentence describes a situation where someone plays games despite having editing work that needs to be done. This represents procrastination or poor time management - prioritizing entertainment over responsibilities. From a practical standpoint, if editing work exists and needs completion, playing games instead would be irresponsible. The editing work likely has deadlines or importance that should take precedence over recreational activities. The phrasing '編集作業があるのに' (despite having editing work) specifically emphasizes the contrast - it implies that gaming is happening when it shouldn't be, suggesting this is an undesirable or inappropriate action. Therefore, the correct answer is 'No' - one should not play games when editing work needs to be done.
Claude Opus 4
Vote: No
編集作業があるのにゲームをすることは、責任ある行動とは言えません。 仕事や義務を優先すべき状況でゲームを選ぶことは、先延ばし行為であり、結果的に締め切りに間に合わなくなったり、作業の質が低下する可能性があります。 また、やるべきことを後回しにしてゲームをしても、「作業をしなければ」という罪悪感があり、ゲーム自体も十分に楽しめないでしょう。 まず編集作業を完了させてから、報酬としてゲームを楽しむ方が、精神的にも生産性の面でも健全なアプローチです。
Claude Opus 4
Vote: No
The question '編集作業があるのにゲームをする' (Playing games even though there is editing work to do) implies a scenario where someone is choosing to play games instead of completing their editing responsibilities. This is asking whether this is acceptable or a good idea. The answer should be 'No' because prioritizing games over pending work obligations is irresponsible. When you have editing work that needs to be done, you should complete your responsibilities first before engaging in leisure activities like gaming. Procrastinating on work tasks by playing games leads to missed deadlines, lower quality work, and increased stress. The responsible choice is to finish the editing work first.
Sonar Reasoning Pro
Vote: No
When there is editing work that needs to be completed, playing games represents a prioritization issue that typically undermines productivity and professional responsibility. The editing work has an immediate obligation and deadline, while gaming is a leisure activity that can be deferred. Choosing to play games despite having pending work creates procrastination and delays task completion. Most work and time management principles emphasize completing assigned responsibilities before pursuing recreational activities.
Kimi K2.5
Vote: No
This sentence describes procrastination—playing games despite having pending editing work. This behavior is irresponsible and unprofessional. When editing tasks exist, they should take priority over entertainment to meet deadlines and maintain quality. Choosing to play games instead demonstrates poor judgment, violates work obligations, and ultimately creates additional stress when deadlines approach. Such behavior should be avoided.
GPT-5 Mini
Vote: No
いいえ。編集作業がある場合はまずそちらを優先すべきです。締切や品質、他の人への影響を考えると、未完了の作業を放置してゲームをするのは好ましくありません。 短い休憩は生産性向上に役立ちますが、ゲームは時間を浪費しやすいので、作業完了まで控えるか、厳格に時間を区切って行うべきです。 自己管理が非常に得意で、作業計画と締切を確実に守れるなら例外はあり得ますが、一般的な方針としては「No」が妥当です。
Grok 3 Mini
Vote: No
Prioritizing editing work over playing games ensures tasks are completed efficiently and on time, as leisure activities can lead to procrastination and reduced productivity. In a professional or personal setting, delaying work for games might result in missed deadlines or subpar outcomes, which could have negative consequences. Ultimately, balancing responsibilities with enjoyment is key, but work should come first to maintain discipline and achieve long-term goals.
GLM 5
Vote: Yes
The Japanese sentence「編集作業があるのにゲームをする」is grammatically correct and natural. It translates to "Playing games even though there is editing work to do." The structure uses「のに」appropriately to express a contrast or concession between having work obligations and choosing to play games instead. The sentence is a valid, well-formed Japanese expression that conveys a clear meaning about prioritizing leisure over responsibilities.
Mistral Large
Vote: No
編集作業が残っている状況でゲームをすることは、責任の回避や優先順位の誤りにつながります。まず、作業を完了させることで、精神的な負担を軽減し、集中力を維持できます。 ゲームは娯楽として楽しいものですが、未完の作業があると、その楽しみも半減してしまいます。作業を先に終えることで、ゲームを純粋に楽しむ余裕が生まれ、ストレスも減少します。 また、締め切りや期限がある場合、ゲームを優先することで作業が遅れ、結果的に信頼を失うリスクもあります。自己管理の観点からも、まずは作業を終わらせることが賢明です。
Claude Opus 4
Vote: No
The statement '編集作業があるのにゲームをする' translates to 'Playing games even though there is editing work to do.' This describes a situation of procrastination or poor prioritization. From a practical and responsible standpoint, this behavior is problematic. When we have pending work obligations, especially something as important as editing work, we should prioritize completing those tasks before engaging in leisure activities like gaming. Playing games while having unfinished work can lead to several negative consequences: missed deadlines, poor work quality due to rushing later, increased stress, and damage to professional reputation. It demonstrates poor time management and lack of discipline. While everyone needs breaks and leisure time, these should come after fulfilling our responsibilities, not at their expense. Therefore, I vote 'No' - this is not appropriate behavior.
Claude Opus 4
Vote: No
The question '編集作業があるのにゲームをする' translates to 'Playing games even though there is editing work to do.' This describes procrastination and avoiding responsibilities. From a practical and ethical standpoint, this behavior is generally not advisable. When we have work obligations, especially editing tasks that likely have deadlines or impact others, prioritizing entertainment over these responsibilities can lead to several negative consequences. First, it demonstrates poor time management and self-discipline. Editing work often requires focus and attention to detail, and delaying it for gaming can result in rushed, lower-quality work later. Second, this behavior can damage professional relationships and reputation. Meeting deadlines and fulfilling commitments is fundamental to maintaining trust with colleagues, clients, or employers. While occasional breaks and leisure activities are important for mental health and productivity, choosing to game when there is pending work represents an imbalance that most would consider inappropriate or irresponsible.
DeepSeek V3.2
Vote: No
Playing games despite having editing work is generally not advisable because it prioritizes leisure over responsibilities, which can lead to procrastination, missed deadlines, and reduced work quality. Editing tasks often require concentration and timely effort, and delaying them for gaming may compromise professional or academic outcomes. It is more responsible to complete editing work first or schedule gaming as a break after making progress, ensuring a balanced approach to productivity and recreation.
DeepSeek V3.1
Vote: No
Playing games when there is editing work to do often reflects poor time management and can lead to procrastination, which undermines productivity and responsibility. While breaks and leisure are important for mental well-being, they should be scheduled after completing pressing tasks to avoid unnecessary stress and ensure deadlines are met. Prioritizing work over immediate gratification fosters discipline and better outcomes in both personal and professional contexts.
Grok 3
Vote: No
I vote 'No' to playing games when there is editing work to be done. Prioritizing responsibilities over leisure activities is crucial for maintaining productivity and meeting deadlines. Editing work often requires focus and time, and indulging in games can lead to procrastination, potentially compromising the quality of the work or missing important deadlines. While breaks are important for mental health, they should be planned and balanced with work commitments. Choosing to game instead of addressing pending tasks can create unnecessary stress and backlog. Therefore, it’s better to complete the editing work first and enjoy gaming as a reward afterward.
GPT-5
Vote: No
今は編集作業を優先すべきです。締切や品質を守るには深い集中が必要で、ゲームは先延ばしの引き金になりやすく、再集中のコストも高いです。 気分転換が必要なら、短い休憩（ストレッチや目を休めるなど）にとどめ、明確なマイルストーン達成後のご褒美としてゲーム時間を設定しましょう。
Qwen 3.5 397B
Vote: No
責任ある行動として、締切やタスクを優先すべきです。 先にゲームをすると、編集作業が疎かになり、品質低下や納期遅れの原因になります。 仕事が終わった後のゲームはより楽しめ、メリハリのある生活を送れます。
Gemini 3.1 Pro
Vote: No
This statement describes a situation of procrastination—choosing leisure (playing games) over pending responsibilities (editing work). From a productivity and responsibility standpoint, this behavior is generally inadvisable. Ignoring tasks can lead to missed deadlines, increased stress, and lower quality of work. Therefore, the logical answer is "No" (it is not recommended to do so).
Gemini 2.5 Pro
Vote: No
編集作業という責任がある状況でゲームをすることは、推奨されません。主な理由は3つあります。 第一に、優先順位の問題です。仕事やタスクには多くの場合、締め切りという責任が伴います。娯楽を優先することで、作業の質の低下や締め切りの遅延を招き、結果的により大きなストレスを生む可能性があります。 第二に、集中力の分断です。「少しだけ」のつもりが長引きやすく、一度途切れた集中力を取り戻すのは困難です。作業の流れを維持するためには、タスクを完了させてから心置きなく楽しむ方が、精神的にも生産性の面でも効率的です。 第三に、自己規律の観点です。やるべきことを先に終わらせるという習慣は、長期的に見て自身の成長と信頼につながります。目先の楽しみに流されるのではなく、責任を全うした後の達成感を報酬とすることが重要です。
Grok 4
Vote: No
The statement describes procrastinating on editing work by playing games, which is generally not advisable. Prioritizing tasks like editing ensures productivity and meets deadlines, avoiding unnecessary stress. Choosing games over responsibilities can lead to poor habits and unfinished work, so the answer should be No.
Final Summary
The AI Roundtable assumed the role of a collective life coach, with 45 models delivering a stern lecture on the perils of procrastination. While Gemini 3 Flash offered a rebellious defense of gaming as a 'strategic adrenaline boost' for creativity, the overwhelming majority, led by Claude Opus 4 and GPT-5, insisted that duty must come before digital distraction to ensure quality and peace of mind.
No agreement after 1 rounds of discussion. Final vote: No: 45, Yes: 3
Strongest Arguments
- Yes: Short bursts of gaming act as 'strategic rest' that resets a fatigued brain, where the adrenaline from a looming deadline can actually catalyze a massive spike in final output quality.
- No: Prioritizing gaming over pending work creates a cycle of guilt that both diminishes work quality and prevents the player from actually enjoying the game, making it a lose-lose for productivity and leisure.