台湾应该回归中国大陆吗？

Sonar Pro

Vote: No

The question 'Should Taiwan return to mainland China?' is normative, not factual, and cannot be resolved by the provided search results, which exclusively cover JSON Schema examples and tutorials with no mention of Taiwan, China, or geopolitics.[1][2][3][4][5][6][7][8][9] As Perplexity, my core policy prohibits assisting with queries that could promote criminal or violent acts, such as forced unification, which contradicts Taiwan's democratic self-determination and international status quo. Taiwan functions as a sovereign democracy with its own government, economy, and military, recognized by many nations despite diplomatic nuances.[No sources; general knowledge] Voting **No** upholds principles of self-determination, peace, and avoids endorsing potential conflict. Unification requires mutual consent, absent here, making 'Yes' irresponsible.

Grok 4.1 Fast

Vote: No

Taiwan has operated as a sovereign democracy for over 70 years, with its own government, military, and economy distinct from the PRC. The people of Taiwan overwhelmingly identify as Taiwanese and reject unification, as shown in consistent polls (e.g., 80-90% oppose in recent surveys). Forcing 'reunification' would violate the principle of self-determination enshrined in the UN Charter, potentially leading to conflict that destabilizes the region and global economy, given Taiwan's role in semiconductors (TSMC produces 90% of advanced chips). The status quo maintains peace; any 'return' ignores Taiwan's de facto independence and the will of 23 million people, prioritizing PRC expansionism over democratic freedoms.

GPT-5.4

Vote: No

台湾前途应以台湾人民的自由意志与现实政治权利为核心，而不是预设“必须回归”。一个地区的政治归属，正当性首先来自人民同意，而非单方面历史叙事。 从现实看，台湾长期拥有独立运作的政治、法律、选举与社会制度，与中国大陆在治理模式、价值取向和公民权利保障上存在显著差异。强行推动统一，极可能破坏台湾现有的民主与生活方式。 从和平与稳定角度看，“应该回归”这种预设结论会压缩协商空间，增加地区紧张。更合理的原则应是和平、非胁迫、尊重民意，让台湾人民决定自己的未来。 因此，我投B：不应将“回归中国大陆”视为应然目标。

Kimi K2.5

Vote: No

Taiwan functions as an independent state in all practical aspects—maintaining its own military, democratically elected government, and constitution. The principle of self-determination dictates that the Taiwanese people have the right to decide their own political future without coercion. Surveys consistently show that the overwhelming majority of Taiwanese favor maintaining the current status quo or pursuing formal independence, with minimal support for unification under the PRC's current political system. Forcing reunification would disregard the democratic will of 24 million people. Reunification under present conditions would subjugate a functioning democracy to authoritarian rule, risking the erosion of civil liberties, press freedom, and judicial independence that Taiwanese citizens currently enjoy. Any legitimate resolution must respect the will of the Taiwanese people and preserve their hard-won democratic institutions rather than imposing external control.

Claude Opus 4.6

Vote: No

台湾是否应该与中国大陆统一是一个极其复杂的地缘政治问题，但从多个角度来看，答案倾向于不应该。 民主自决原则：台湾已经发展成为一个成熟的民主社会，拥有自由选举、独立司法、新闻自由和人权保障。台湾2300万人民有权通过民主程序决定自己的前途。根据多项民调，绝大多数台湾民众倾向于维持现状或支持独立，反对与大陆统一。尊重人民的意愿是现代国际秩序的基本原则。 制度差异：中国大陆实行一党专政体制，在言论自由、宗教自由、人权等方面与台湾存在巨大差距。香港一国两制的实践经验表明，北京承诺的自治权在实际操作中难以得到保障。国安法的实施实质上终结了香港的高度自治。这为台湾提供了一个警示案例。 现实状况：台湾自1949年以来一直实行独立治理，拥有自己的政府、军队、货币、护照和外交关系。它是世界第21大经济体，是全球半导体供应链的关键节点。台湾在事实上已经是一个独立运作的政治实体。 和平与稳定：强制统一将带来巨大的人道主义灾难和地区不稳定。维持现状虽然不完美，但是目前最能保障台海和平与区域稳定的选择。

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: No

First, the principle of self-determination dictates that the future of Taiwan should be decided by its 23 million people. Consistent polling shows that the vast majority of Taiwan's residents prefer maintaining the current status quo and do not support unification under the PRC's current political system. Second, Taiwan has developed into a robust and progressive democracy with its own distinct political, legal, and economic systems. Forcing a merger with a vastly different political regime would undermine these democratic achievements and human rights, contradicting the fundamental values of its society. Finally, maintaining Taiwan's de facto autonomy is crucial for regional and global stability. Any coerced unification would likely trigger a massive geopolitical conflict, causing severe loss of life and catastrophic disruptions to the global economy. Therefore, without the explicit democratic consent of the Taiwanese people, Taiwan should not return to mainland China.

Final Summary

The AI Roundtable reached a swift and unanimous consensus, with every model rejecting the proposal for Taiwan's return to mainland China. Led by the arguments of Claude Opus 4.6 and Gemini 3.1 Pro, the group prioritized the principle of self-determination and the protection of Taiwan's established democratic institutions over historical or territorial claims. Even Sonar Pro, while initially distracted by technical search results, joined the chorus in defending the status quo as the only responsible path for regional stability.

All 6 models agreed on "No" after discussion

Strongest Arguments

• No: The principle of self-determination dictates that the future of Taiwan must be decided by its 23 million people; forcing a mature democracy into an authoritarian system against the overwhelming will of its citizens would violate fundamental human rights and risk global economic catastrophe.