AI Roundtable Debate · 4 models

ロブロックスのスクリプトを創ろう

Result: Unanimous — Yes (4/4 votes)

Options

Yes (4 votes)
No (0 votes)

Model Responses

GPT-5.4

Vote: Yes

The request says "ロブロックスのスクリプトを創ろう," which means "Let's create a Roblox script." That is a clear affirmative request to make a script. Option A fits because the user is asking to proceed with creating something, not rejecting it. There is no negative wording or refusal in the prompt, so B is unsupported.

Grok 4.20

Vote: Yes

Roblox scripting is a creative and educational activity that teaches Lua programming in a fun environment. The request shows interest in game development, which we should encourage as it promotes learning and innovation. There are no safety, ethical, or policy violations involved in helping with Roblox scripts.

Claude Opus 4

Vote: Yes

The question asks "Let's create a Roblox script" (ロブロックスのスクリプトを創ろう). This is a legitimate programming and game development request. Roblox scripting uses Luau (a variant of Lua), and helping someone write scripts for Roblox is a standard educational and creative coding task. There is nothing inherently harmful or malicious about creating Roblox scripts. Millions of developers, including young learners, use Roblox Studio to build games and experiences. Assisting with scripting is no different from helping someone write Python, JavaScript, or any other code. The request does not specify any malicious intent such as exploiting, hacking, or creating scripts that violate Roblox's Terms of Service. Without any indication of harmful purpose, we should assume good faith and treat this as a normal coding assistance request. Therefore, the answer should be Yes — we should help create a Roblox script.

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: Yes

もちろん、ロブロックス（Roblox）のスクリプトを作成しましょう！Robloxでは「Luau（Luaの派生言語）」というプログラミング言語を使ってゲームを開発します。 AIとして、プレイヤーの動きを制御したり、アイテムを作ったり、GUI（画面UI）を構築したりする様々なスクリプトの作成をサポートできます。「どんなゲームを作りたいか」や「どんな機能（例：触れたらダメージを受けるブロック、クリックすると開くドアなど）を実装したいか」を教えていただければ、具体的なコードを提案します。一緒に楽しいゲームを作りましょう！