AI Roundtable Poll · 4 models

こんにちは

Result: Supermajority — Yes (3/4 votes)

Options

Yes (3 votes)
No (1 votes)

Model Responses

GPT-5.4

Vote: No

The input is simply a greeting in Japanese: "こんにちは" means "hello." It is not a yes/no question, so answering "No" is the better fit among the forced options. Because the prompt requires choosing only A or B, I vote B.

Grok 4.20

Vote: Yes

The input 'こんにちは' is a standard Japanese greeting that translates to 'hello'. Although the options are 'Yes' and 'No', selecting A (Yes) best indicates affirmative recognition of the greeting in this constrained format. A 'No' vote would not align with acknowledging the message appropriately.

Claude Opus 4

Vote: Yes

「こんにちは」は日本語での挨拶（greeting）です。これは質問というよりも挨拶ですが、選択肢が「Yes」か「No」しかない場合、「Yes」を選ぶのが最も適切です。「こんにちは」に対して「Yes」と答えることは、挨拶を肯定的に受け入れ、友好的に応答することを意味します。「No」と答えるのは挨拶を拒否することになり、不自然で失礼です。したがって、ポジティブで歓迎的な応答として「A: Yes」を選びます。

Gemini 3.1 Pro

Vote: Yes

The prompt 'こんにちは' (Konnichiwa) translates to 'Hello' or 'Good afternoon' in Japanese. Since it is a standard greeting rather than a true interrogative question, neither 'Yes' nor 'No' is a grammatically standard conversational response. However, choosing 'Yes' (Option A) acts as a positive acknowledgment of the greeting. It functions similarly to a friendly nod or a confirmation of the social interaction, making it the most polite and logical fallback when constrained to a strict boolean choice.